What can you comfortably afford around Columbus?
By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated
Maybe the pre-approval letter came back with a bigger number than you expected, and you're not sure you should trust it. Maybe a mortgage calculator gave you one number and your gut gave you another. Whatever brought you here, the number worth starting with is the monthly payment you'd be comfortable making for years, with room left over for the rest of your life.
Being approved for an amount doesn't mean you should spend all of it, and no two households' months look the same, so there isn't one right answer here. This page walks through how to find your own number and what it really buys around Columbus, including when waiting a little longer is the better plan. I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty, and if the honest answer is to keep renting and saving for now, I'll tell you that too.
Tell me roughly what you take home each month and what your month already costs, and I'll show you the payment that fits and what it buys in the places you're looking. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
Start from where you are
Pick the line that sounds most like you.
I'm wondering whether buying makes sense for me at all right now.
The best place to start is the monthly payment you'd be comfortable with while you keep saving and still have room for surprises, because that number tells you whether buying makes sense this year or a little later, and either answer is okay. A lender will look at your income before taxes, but you pay your bills with what actually lands in your account, so the steps below start there.
I've got a pre-approval or a calculator number, and it feels like a lot.
A pre-approval tells you the most a lender is willing to lend, and the number that matters more is the payment you can live with month after month, after savings, car payments, childcare and everything else your budget already carries. The calculator below puts your comfortable number next to a lender-style maximum, using your own take-home pay and the property tax rate for the school district you pick, and nothing you type leaves this page unless you decide to send it.
I know the payment I'm comfortable with, and I'd like to see what it buys.
When you already know your number, the next step is a search built around it, with the property taxes and any association or community charges for each address added in before you fall for a house.
Approved and comfortable are two different numbers
A lender works from your income before taxes and the debts on your credit report, and on many loans it lets those debts plus the house payment reach close to half of that income. It never sees what groceries, childcare or savings cost you.
A worked example, line by line, is in the guide on being approved for more than you want to spend.
Your comfortable number, step by step
You can do this at a kitchen table with a pay stub and a bank statement, or in the calculator below, which never asks your name.
- Start with what lands in your bank account in a typical month.
- Add up what your month costs before housing, savings included.
- Set aside utilities and a repair fund for the house itself.
- What's left is the most your full house payment should be.
- Leave room to breathe, with savings still there after closing.
Step 1 of 5. What lands in your account
Or enter one paycheck and how often you're paid
How living there changes your paycheck
Your comfortable number
Compare with a lender's mathOptional
Where you live changes your paycheck too
Most Central Ohio cities credit the tax you pay where you work, so living in one and working in another costs little. The Village of Plain City doesn't, so a resident working in Dublin pays both, and Jonathan Alder schools add their own income tax. The calculator can take that out of your take-home pay, and other cities are on the page about local income tax by city.
Help with the down payment in Ohio
The Ohio Housing Finance Agency offers 3% to 3.5% of the price as a second mortgage that's forgiven after seven years, or repaid in full if you sell sooner. It usually carries a higher rate, so it's a good trade when cash is all that stands between you and a house that fits. City and county programs, and who qualifies, are in the guide to Ohio down payment help.
Ways to make the number work
- Look across a school district line for a smaller tax bill on the same price.
- Pay off the biggest monthly debt first, since a lender counts every monthly debt payment against the loan.
- Ask a seller whose house has sat a while to cover closing costs or buy down your rate, which can beat a small price cut.
- Compare a townhome or a smaller house, dues included.
- Compare Loan Estimates from two or three lenders, line by line.
- Budget a builder's low rate at what it becomes once any buydown ends.
When waiting is the smarter move
If the payment that fits won't buy a house you'd want, or would leave almost nothing in savings after closing, a few more months of renting and saving is a good plan. The same goes when a move is coming, since buying and selling within a few years usually costs more than renting. Waiting only for rates to fall is harder to justify, because nobody knows where they'll go, and a payment that only works after a refinance is a bet.
How long it takes for buying to pull ahead of renting a comparable house around Columbus is in the rent-or-buy guide. If you wait, I'll help you set a date and a savings target.
How I'd help, and where I stop
Once you know your number, I'll show you what it buys where you're looking, with each address's real property taxes and association charges added in, so the payment you see on paper is the one you'd actually make.
Questions and numbers are free, and you don't sign anything to get them. If you want to tour homes with me, Ohio rules and the MLS require a short written agreement first. I'll walk you through it before you sign.
When we look at houses, I'll also tell you when one needs more set aside for repairs than its listing lets on, because I buy and renovate houses and know what an old furnace or a tired roof costs to replace.
The loan itself is your lender's call, so a real pre-approval and a Loan Estimate come from a lender, ideally two or three so you can see the differences. If you'd like a name, I work with a loan officer at NFM Lending. I don't get paid for that referral, and you're always free to compare other lenders. For a free, neutral look at your budget first, a HUD-approved housing counselor, opens in a new tab can do that, and some down payment programs require a class with one anyway.
Here's how this usually goes
A common pattern, not one specific client.
Usually the approval comes back higher than anyone planned on. Before we look at houses, we work out the monthly payment that fits after everything else the month already costs, with property taxes and insurance counted in. A home search site's tax estimate can be off by hundreds of dollars a month, so I check the county's own numbers for any house you're serious about, and we shop at or below the number you set.
From a Google review
We had so many questions throughout the process and Aaron had answers and solutions for every single one.
Questions people ask
Should I spend everything I'm approved for?
How much of my income should go to my house payment?
Does the comfortable number include taxes and insurance?
Will checking my numbers hurt my credit?
Can I buy a house in Ohio with little or no money down?
Find the payment that fits your month
Tell me roughly what you take home each month and what your month already costs, and I'll show you the payment that fits and what it buys in the places you're looking. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
Rather write it out?
Guides for this situation
Sources
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-02, Debt-to-Income Ratios, dated Apr 2, 2025: 36% for manually underwritten loans, up to 45% with credit score and reserve requirements, and up to 50% through Desktop Underwriter, seen 2026-10-26. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, “How can I figure out if I can afford to buy a home and take out a mortgage?”, last reviewed June 27, 2024, seen 2026-10-26.
- Village of Plain City, Income Tax FAQ, seen 2026-10-26, and City of Columbus Income Tax Division, municipal tax list showing Plain City at 1.5% with 0% credit, seen 2026-10-26. Ohio Department of Taxation, School Districts With an Income Tax for 2026: Jonathan Alder 1.25%, seen 2026-10-26. WOSU, May 5, 2026: Jonathan Alder's 0.75% income tax renewal passed for 10 years, per unofficial results.
- Ohio Housing Finance Agency, Programs at a Glance, updated Aug 27, 2025: 3% on conventional or 3.5% on government loans, “Seven-year forgivable second mortgage,” “All repayable if buyer sells home prior to seven years,” seen 2026-10-26. OHFA mortgage rates, updated Oct 26, 2026, list a higher rate on its loans with down payment assistance than without it, seen 2026-10-26.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B2-1.4-04, Temporary Interest Rate Buydowns, dated Aug 7, 2024: borrowers qualify at the note rate, not the bought-down rate. Seller contributions have limits that differ by loan type, per Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02 and the FHA and VA rules.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, “What happens when a mortgage lender checks my credit?”, last reviewed Aug 28, 2026, seen 2026-10-26.
Updated .
