Fix it up or sell it as-is? How to decide in Central Ohio
By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated
Maybe the roof is close to done, the kitchen hasn't changed since the house was built, and you're not sure you have the money or the energy to fix any of it. Maybe a buyer's inspection already turned up a list you didn't expect.
A house that needs work can still sell well around here, and you have more than one way to do it. I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty, and I buy and renovate houses myself, so I'll give you my honest read on which repairs come back to you in the price and which ones don't.
Send the address and a few phone photos of the rough spots. I'll come back with what it would likely bring as it is, what it could net after the repairs that pay you back, and what I'd skip. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
Or call (614) 578-5484.
Start from where you are
Pick the line that sounds most like you.
I just found out how much it needs, and I'm a little overwhelmed.
Plenty of houses around Columbus sell every month with old roofs, original kitchens and long inspection lists, so a long list is something to plan around, and you still have more than one good way to sell.
I'm trying to decide whether to fix things or sell it as it is.
Most of the time the answer lands somewhere in the middle, with a short list of repairs that come back to you in the price and a longer list that buyers will simply price in, and the trick is knowing which is which before you spend anything.
I've made up my mind and want a plan and a price.
When you're ready, I'll walk through the house with you, in person or on video, and give you a written list of what's worth fixing, what's fine to leave and what the house would likely bring each way.
What a house that needs work usually means
Some houses just got older while the people in them got busier, and some belonged to a parent who couldn't keep up with things in the last few years. Whatever the reason, most owners in this spot feel a little embarrassed and worried about getting lowballed, especially if a postcard offering to buy the house has already shown up in the mailbox.
The practical problem is that a few specific repairs can limit who's able to buy the house. An FHA appraiser can require fixes for safety problems, like an active leak or peeling paint on an older home, before the loan will close, so one or two problems can shrink the buyer pool more than the rest of the house combined.
Selling as-is in Ohio
You can sell a house as-is in Ohio, which means you tell buyers up front that you won't make repairs. That doesn't let you skip the paperwork, though. Most sellers still have to fill out Ohio's residential property disclosure form, which asks what you actually know about the roof, the basement, the mechanicals and other parts of the house, and if a buyer gets the form after signing a contract, they can back out within three business days.
If the house was built before 1978, there's a federal lead paint disclosure too. Estates sold by an executor and court-ordered sales are among the exceptions to Ohio's form, and if you think you might be exempt, ask your attorney before you skip it.
Ways to sell a house that needs work
Fix the few things that matter, then list it. This usually brings the best net when the house is basically sound. It means fixing anything that would stop a buyer's loan or scare an inspector, then doing the inexpensive work that changes how the house photographs, like paint, cleaning, light fixtures and a tidied-up yard.
List it as-is on the open market. Plenty of buyers around Columbus are looking for a project, and investors are an active part of this market, so an as-is house listed where every buyer can see it, at the right price, can draw more than one offer. You skip the repairs and the contractors and still get competition for the house.
Take a private as-is cash offer. This trades some of the price for certainty and a closing date you pick. It makes the most sense when the house needs a lot, when you can't carry it for a couple of months, or when you're managing it from far away.
Whichever way you lean, I'd price the house twice from real nearby sales, once as it stands and once after a short repair list, then subtract the repair cost and the extra months of carrying it. What's left is the true payoff of fixing, and sometimes it's a lot smaller than people expect.
What a remodel gets back when you sell
A minor kitchen upgrade gets back about 60% of its cost when the house sells. So a dollar spent remodeling right before a sale usually brings back about 60 cents, and that money does more good fixing what a buyer's inspector or lender would flag.
When waiting is the smarter move
The kind of waiting that usually pays off here is waiting a couple of weeks for real repair numbers. If you don't know what the big repair actually costs, get two contractor bids before you decide anything, because a guess on a roof or a foundation can swing the whole decision. And if you still live there, the house is paid off and you can handle small repairs over the winter, listing in spring with a cleaner inspection report is a perfectly good plan.
If an estate can't sign yet or the family hasn't agreed, that's a reason to wait too, and nobody should be hurried into a sale before they're allowed to make one.
Every number, side by side
Before you sign anything with anyone, I can put three columns in front of you. One shows what the house would likely net after the few repairs that pay back, one shows what it would net listed as it is, and one shows a cash number from Wright Home Offer, a company I co-own that buys houses as-is. Every column uses the same date, the same payoff and the same facts about the house, and each one is labeled as an estimate. If listing nets you more, I'll tell you to list.
I'm a licensed agent with Red 1 Realty, and I co-own Wright Home Offer. If you sell to Wright Home Offer, I'm on the buyer's side, not your agent, and the company expects to make a profit. You'll get this in writing to sign before we talk numbers, and you're welcome to have your own agent or attorney look at anything.
How I'd help, and where I stop
I'll walk through the house with you, in person or on a video call, and if something big turns up, like a foundation crack or a roof that's done, I'll send you to a licensed inspector or two contractors for real numbers, because those calls are theirs to make. I won't tell you to hide a problem, and I won't suggest skipping a form you're required to fill out.
Here's how this usually goes
A common pattern, not one specific client.
Usually the owner has a long list of what's wrong with the house and assumes all of it has to be fixed before anyone will make an offer. We walk through together and sort that list into what buyers will pay for, what's fine to leave alone and what goes on Ohio's disclosure form either way. That way you know which repairs earn back what they cost before you spend anything.
From a Google review
He didn't have us make any unnecessary updates and provided a manageable list of things to do to prepare the house to be sold.
Questions people ask
Can you sell a house as-is in Ohio?
Should I replace the roof before selling?
How much less do investors pay?
What shouldn't I bother fixing?
Let's look at it together
Send the address and a few phone photos of the rough spots. I'll come back with what it would likely bring as it is, what it could net after the repairs that pay you back, and what I'd skip. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
Or call (614) 578-5484.
Rather write it out?
Guides for this situation
Sources
- Ohio Revised Code 5302.30, residential property disclosure form, exemptions and three-business-day rescission, codes.ohio.gov, seen 2026-10-25.
- U.S. EPA, Real Estate Disclosures about Potential Lead Hazards, epa.gov/lead/real-estate-disclosures-about-potential-lead-hazards, seen 2026-10-25.
- HUD Handbook 4000.1, FHA appraisal and minimum property standards, hud.gov, via secondary summaries, seen 2026-10-25.
- Investor activity: Redfin, investor home purchases Q1 2026, published May 28, 2026, and ATTOM Q2 2026 home flipping report, published Oct 1, 2026.
- National Association of REALTORS®, 2025 Remodeling Impact Report, published Apr 9, 2025: a minor kitchen upgrade recovers an estimated 60% of its cost.
Updated .
