Skip to content
Aaron LeddyRed 1 RealtyREALTOR®

Selling or keeping the house in an Ohio divorce

By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated

Maybe one of you is staying in the house for now, or maybe neither of you wants it and you just need it sold without another argument. Either way, the first thing you both need is a value you can trust, and it helps when it comes from one person, with the same numbers, on the same day.

This page covers how a house usually gets sold or bought out during a divorce in Ohio, and where your attorneys or mediator come in. I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty, and whichever of you calls first, the numbers I give you are the same ones the other person would get from me.

I'll send the same value range and the same net sheet to both of you, or to your attorneys or mediator, so everyone's working from one number. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or call (614) 578-5484.

Start from where you are

Pick the line that sounds most like you.

We're just starting to separate, and I don't know what happens to the house.

In the first weeks of a separation, nothing about the house has to be decided, and before either of you moves out, changes who pays the mortgage or signs anything about the house, it's worth a quick conversation with your attorney.

How the house is handled in an Ohio divorce

We're working out whether one of us keeps it or we sell.

This is usually when the house turns into a math problem, because keeping it tends to mean one of you refinancing alone and buying out the other's share. It helps to start from a value you both trust and a lender's straight answer about what one income can carry.

Selling, a buyout or waiting

We've agreed on a plan and need it handled fairly.

Once you've agreed on a sale or a buyout, the goal is a clean finish, with both of you getting the same numbers at the same time, both signing what needs signing and every update going wherever your attorneys or mediator want it to go.

One number, for both of you

What makes the house the hardest part

The house is usually the biggest thing you own together, and it's tied up with everything else, like where the kids will sleep and whether a payment that worked on two incomes can work on one. It's also where trust runs thinnest, because each of you may assume the other person's agent is really on the other side.

That's why I work from one set of numbers, sent to both of you at the same time once you're both part of the conversation, and why I won't give one of you a different number in private. I won't contact your spouse on my own before you're ready, and if safety is a concern at all, I'll go through your attorneys for everything and never share one person's address or schedule with the other.

How the house is handled in an Ohio divorce

Ohio divides marital property equally unless the court finds that wouldn't be fair, and the house is usually the largest piece of it. A house one of you owned before the marriage can be treated differently, which is a question for your attorney.

Timing depends on which process you're in. In a dissolution, you agree on everything up front, including the house, and the court hearing happens 30 to 90 days after filing, after which the property division generally can't be reopened. A divorce can take months longer, and in Franklin County, filing the complaint automatically puts an order in place that keeps either spouse from selling or borrowing against the house without the other's agreement or a court order.

So before anyone signs a listing agreement, check with your attorney whether an order like that is in effect, and plan on both of you signing if you're both on the title.

Selling, a buyout or waiting

Selling and splitting what's left. This is the simplest path when neither of you can or wants to carry the house alone. Both of you sign the listing, everything that matters goes to both of you, and the price comes from what's actually closing near the house this fall, which can differ in either direction from an appraisal your attorneys ordered.

One of you keeps it. This usually means buying out the other person's share of the equity and refinancing the whole loan in one name at today's rate. A transfer between spouses in a divorce generally won't trigger the loan's due-on-sale clause, but it also won't take the departing spouse's name off the loan, and only the lender can release them.

Pricing it either way. Price the house to what similar homes are actually selling for, because a listing that starts too high and sits tends to turn into an argument about whose fault it is, and both of you end up paying for the cuts. Buyout math has judgment calls in it too, like whether expected selling costs get subtracted from the equity being bought out, so I'll lay the numbers out both ways and let your attorneys or mediator decide.

When waiting is the smarter move

Waiting can be the kinder choice, and sometimes the cheaper one. If you can both afford the house and the kids are partway through a school year, a sale date written into the decree can work better than a rushed sale, and your attorneys can tell you how that's usually set up. If the buyout only works on paper at today's rate, waiting beats a refinance that leaves the person keeping the house stretched every month.

And if one of you isn't ready to sell, a listing one owner is quietly fighting rarely goes well, so it's usually better to wait for an agreement or a court order first.

When a quick, clean sale matters more to both of you

In a few cases, a quick, clean sale matters more to both of you than the last dollar, usually when the house needs work neither of you wants to pay for. Then I can get an as-is cash number from Wright Home Offer, a company I co-own, and put it next to what the house would likely net on the market, in writing, sent to both of you at the same time. If either of you would rather not consider it, I'll stick to listing, and if listing nets more, I'll tell you to list.

I'm a licensed agent with Red 1 Realty, and I co-own Wright Home Offer. If you sell to Wright Home Offer, I'm on the buyer's side, not your agent, and the company expects to make a profit. You'll get this in writing to sign before we talk numbers, and you're welcome to have your own agent or attorney look at anything.

How I'd help, and where I stop

My part is the house, which means one value report, one net sheet and every update going to both of you, or to your attorneys, at the same time. I've helped a lot of people through this over the years. Even when there's a lot you don't agree on, you usually share one goal, which is to move on to the next chapter with a clean slate, and I can be a good middle ground for the communication between you on the way there.

I don't give legal advice about who gets the house or how to divide anything else, and taxes on the sale belong with a CPA, especially the question of selling before or after the divorce is final, because the answer can change how much of the gain is taxed.

Here's how this usually goes

A common pattern, not one specific client.

Usually one of you calls first, sometimes with the other's blessing and sometimes without it, and the worry underneath is whether the number will be fair. I suggest that both of you, or both attorneys, get the same value report in the same message, so nobody wonders whose side it's on. From there it's usually selling now, one of you buying the other out or waiting a while, and I'll show you what each looks like in dollars. If one of you wants to keep the house, a lender's pre-approval for the refinance comes before anyone agrees on a buyout price, and the legal and tax questions stay with your attorneys and a CPA.

Questions people ask

Can I sell the house before the divorce is final?
Often, yes, as long as both owners agree or the court allows it. In Franklin County, filing for divorce puts an automatic order in place that limits selling the house, so check with your attorney before you list. In a dissolution, the house is handled in the agreement you both sign.
Who gets the house in an Ohio divorce?
Ohio starts from an equal division of marital property, and the house is usually part of that, but the details depend on your situation and belong with your attorney. What I can give you is a reliable value, so the conversation starts from real numbers.
Can one of us take over the mortgage?
Sometimes. A transfer between spouses in a divorce generally doesn't trigger the due-on-sale clause, but taking the departing spouse off the loan takes the lender's approval, which usually means the person keeping the house has to qualify alone. Some FHA and VA loans can be assumed if the lender approves.
Do we need an appraisal or a market analysis?
Attorneys often order an appraisal for a buyout. If the house is being sold, the list price should come from what's closing nearby right now, and I'll explain any difference between the two in plain words, to both of you.

One number, for both of you

I'll send the same value range and the same net sheet to both of you, or to your attorneys or mediator, so everyone's working from one number. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or call (614) 578-5484.

Rather write it out?
If you'd rather type than text, leave your name, your number and a line about what's going on.

I'll call or text from (614) 578-5484.

Optional if you leave a phone number.

Street and city is plenty.

Should I send the value to both of you, or to your attorneys?(optional)

If it's just you for now, that's fine, and I won't contact your spouse on my own. Whenever they or their attorney ask, they'll get the same numbers you did, never a different version.

How should I reach you?(optional)

I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

See the Privacy Policy and text message terms.

Guides for this situation

Sources

  • Ohio Revised Code 3105.171 (division of marital property shall be equal, with exceptions, and separate property), effective 2025-09-30, codes.ohio.gov, seen 2026-10-25.
  • Ohio Revised Code 3105.64 (dissolution hearing not less than 30 nor more than 90 days after filing), codes.ohio.gov, and Supreme Court of Ohio Dissolution Bench Card, revised Sept 2024, seen 2026-10-25.
  • Franklin County Domestic Relations Local Rule 43 and form eDR3006, standard mutual temporary restraining order, drj.fccourts.org, seen 2026-10-25.
  • 12 U.S.C. 1701j-3(d)(7), law.cornell.edu, seen 2026-10-25.
  • Fannie Mae Servicing Guide D1-4.1-02 and HUD guidance on FHA assumptions, via search summary, 2026-10-25.

Updated .

Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty

Aaron Leddy

Red 1 Realty

REALTOR®

(614) 578-5484

Brokered by

Red 1 Realty