Skip to content
Aaron LeddyRed 1 RealtyREALTOR®

When your offers keep losing on houses around Columbus

By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated

Maybe you've written two or three offers and watched each house go to someone else, or maybe a contract you were excited about fell apart a week before closing. Either way, it's normal to feel worn out and a little doubtful about the whole thing.

This page walks through why offers usually lose this fall, what sellers weigh besides the price, and how to write the next one without giving up the protections that matter to you. I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty, and I'll read your last offer the way the seller's side did.

Send me the address and what you offered, and I'll tell you what likely decided it and what I'd change on the next one. If you're working with another agent under a buyer agreement, talk with them first. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or call (614) 578-5484.

Start from where you are

Pick the line that sounds most like you.

We just lost one, and we need a minute before the next.

Losing a house you'd already started picturing yourself in is a real letdown, and taking a week off before the next one is a perfectly good idea, because tired buyers tend to overpay or give up protections they later wish they'd kept.

See why offers usually lose

We're trying to figure out why our offers aren't winning.

Plenty of offers lose for reasons besides the price, like the financing terms, the inspection window or a closing date that didn't fit the seller, and the last offer you wrote usually shows which one it was.

Go through your last offer

We've found another house and want this offer to be the one.

When you're ready to try again, the strongest offers usually come from knowing what this seller cares about besides price and writing terms that fit it, while keeping the protections that matter most to you.

Look at the last offer before you write the next one

Why offers lose this fall

There are more homes for sale around Columbus than a year ago, so losing again can feel strange. The houses that draw a crowd are the ones priced right, in good shape and in the places buyers want to be, and those can still sell close to asking, sometimes with more than one offer on the table.

When an offer loses on one of those houses, it's usually for one of a few reasons, and price is only one of them. Another buyer's terms may have looked more certain to close, their closing date may have fit the seller's move better, or their offer may simply have arrived while yours was still being written.

Reading your last offer

Your last offer usually tells you more than the rejection did. Pull it up and read it the way the seller did, starting with these:

  • The price, next to what similar houses nearby actually went under contract for.
  • How you're paying, including the loan type, how your pre-approval letter read and how much earnest money you put down.
  • The inspection terms, meaning how many days you asked for and what you said you'd do if the inspector found something.
  • What happens if the appraisal comes in low, a line sellers read closely when the price is at the high end of what similar houses sold for.
  • The closing date and when you'd move in, next to when the seller needed to be out.

It's also fair to have your agent ask the listing agent what tipped it, and many will tell you.

What you can change on the next offer

The price, up to your number. Offering more can win a house, and the ceiling is the payment you're comfortable with, so set it before you shop and let a house go if winning it means going past that.

The terms. A closing date that fits the seller, a lender who answers the phone when the listing agent calls and earnest money that shows you're serious can make an offer read as more certain without costing you much.

The protections, carefully. Some buyers shorten the inspection period or agree not to ask for small repairs, which keeps the protection that matters most, the chance to walk away if something big turns up. Giving up the inspection or the appraisal protection altogether is a bigger risk, and it's your call to make with your eyes open.

The house. Houses that have been on the market a month or more, or already had a price cut, usually leave more room to negotiate, and some of them fit just as well as the one that drew a crowd.

How close to asking homes are selling

In September, Central Ohio buyers paid about 99% of the final asking price on the homes that sold. On houses that are priced right, there usually isn't much room below asking, so when two offers land close together, the terms often decide which one the seller picks.

When waiting is the smarter move

If winning keeps meaning a payment past what you're comfortable with, or you've started thinking about skipping the inspection on an older house just to get one, that's a good time to stop for a few weeks. New listings keep coming, and the right house at a payment that fits is worth more than the next one that happens to be available.

Stepping back is also how a lot of buyers notice the houses that have sat a while, where the seller is more open to terms that work for you.

If a contract fell apart before closing

If you were already under contract when it ended, what happens next depends on why it ended and what the contract says, including what happens to your earnest money. Read the release carefully before you sign it, and ask an attorney about anything in it that's unclear.

Then give yourself a little time, because a deal that falls through stings more than a lost offer, and the next search usually goes better with what you learned from the last house.

How I'd help, and where I stop

When we look at your last offer together, I'll put it next to what similar houses nearby actually went under contract for and read the terms the way the seller's side would, so the changes for next time are specific. On the next house, I'll find out what the seller cares about before we write anything, like the closing date they need, and we'll build the offer around that without stretching your budget or dropping the protections you want to keep.

If you're working with another agent under a buyer agreement, they're the right person to go through your offers with. Your lender decides the financing terms, and a question about a contract dispute or your earnest money belongs with an attorney.

Here's how this usually goes

A common pattern, not one specific client.

Usually it's after the second or third house goes to someone else, when it starts to feel personal. We pull up the last offer and read it the way the seller did, looking at the closing date, the inspection terms and how solid the financing looked next to the price. Sometimes the house was priced to draw a crowd, and sometimes one term made a strong offer read as a risky one. Then we decide together what to change on the next offer, so it's stronger without stretching the budget.

Questions people ask

Why was my offer rejected without a counteroffer?
Usually because the seller had a stronger offer in hand, or yours was far enough from what they'd accept that a counter didn't seem worth it. Your agent can ask the listing agent what decided it, and that answer is worth having before you write the next one.
How far below asking can I offer around Columbus right now?
On a house that's priced right, usually not far, since buyers paid about 99% of the final asking price on the homes that sold in September. Houses that have sat a month or more, or already had a price cut, tend to leave more room.
Should I waive the inspection to win?
That's your call, and on an older house it's a big risk, since the inspection is your best chance to learn about the roof, the furnace or the foundation before you own them. A shorter inspection period, or agreeing not to ask for small repairs, can make an offer read cleaner while keeping your chance to walk away if something big turns up.
What happens to my earnest money if the deal falls through?
It depends on why the contract ended and what it says, so read the release before you sign it. If you and the seller disagree about who gets it, that's a question for an attorney.

Look at the last offer before you write the next one

Send me the address and what you offered, and I'll tell you what likely decided it and what I'd change on the next one. If you're working with another agent under a buyer agreement, talk with them first. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or call (614) 578-5484.

Rather write it out?
If you'd rather type than text, leave your name, your number and a line about what's going on.

I'll call or text from (614) 578-5484.

Optional if you leave a phone number.

Street and city is plenty.

How should I reach you?(optional)

I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

See the Privacy Policy and text message terms.

Sources

  • Columbus REALTORS, Central Ohio Housing Report for September 2026, published Oct 13, 2026: 98.8% of final list price received, and homes for sale up 12.3% from a year earlier, columbusrealtors.com.

Updated .

Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty

Aaron Leddy

Red 1 Realty

REALTOR®

(614) 578-5484

Brokered by

Red 1 Realty