Approved for $400,000?
What you can comfortably afford instead
By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated · 7-minute read
The short answer. A pre-approval is the most a lender will let you borrow, worked out from your income before taxes and the debts on your credit report. What you can comfortably afford starts from what actually lands in your account and what your month already costs, and for a lot of households it's well below the approval. Find that monthly number first, then shop at or under it.
Tell me roughly what you take home each month and what your month already costs, and I'll show you the payment that fits and what it buys in the places you're looking. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
If a pre-approval letter just came back for $400,000, or something close to it, you're probably feeling a mix of excitement and a little dread, because it's more than you'd planned on and you're not sure whether to trust it. That reaction is worth listening to, because nothing about the letter says you have to spend all of it.
This guide walks through what the approval actually measures, one Central Ohio household's approved and comfortable numbers side by side, and how to find your own. It's part of my guide to what you can really afford. I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty, and I'd like the house you buy to leave room in your month for everything else you care about.
What a pre-approval actually measures
A lender starts with your income before taxes, then adds your new house payment to the monthly debts on your credit report, like car loans, student loans and card minimums. On a conventional loan, Fannie Mae's guidelines let that total reach 45% of your income in many cases and up to 50% through its automated system, and FHA, VA and USDA loans each have their own ceilings.¹ That's how a lender measures the risk of lending to you, and it doesn't tell you whether the payment leaves room for the rest of your life.
It also leaves out a lot of what your month really costs. Groceries, childcare, car insurance, phone bills, giving and the money you put into savings don't appear on a credit report, so they don't appear in the approval either. As the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau puts it, how much you could borrow "is very different from how much you can afford to repay without stretching your budget for other important items too thin."²
One household, two numbers
Here's how the gap looks for an ordinary household, worked out with this year's tax rates. They earn $115,000 a year in wages between them, save for retirement and get their health insurance through work, and carry a car payment and a student loan. After taxes, retirement and health insurance come out, about $6,960 lands in their account each month.³
None of that means they can't buy at $400,000. They might decide a bigger yard is worth saving less for a few years, and that's their call to make. The point is to make it on purpose, with the real monthly number in front of them.
Why the approval runs so much higher
Most of the gap comes from the difference between what you earn and what you keep. For the household above, about $2,630 of its $9,580 in monthly income goes to taxes, retirement and health insurance before it ever reaches the bank.³ Around Columbus that includes a city income tax, and in some places a school district income tax on top, and an approval built on income before taxes doesn't see either one.
The rest comes from costs that never show up on a credit report, like childcare, utilities, a repair fund and the savings you want to keep making. Those are real bills, and you're the only one who knows what they are. Property taxes add one more wrinkle here, because they follow the school district the parcel sits in, so the same price can carry a different payment a few miles away.
Finding your own comfortable number
Start with your bank statement, since it shows what actually arrives each month after every deduction, and add up every paycheck for everyone who'll be on the loan. Then list what goes out before housing, and be honest about the spending money you'll really keep using, because a budget that only works if you never eat out again usually doesn't last.
Take out what a house costs beyond the mortgage, which means utilities and a repair fund, and whatever's left is the most your full house payment should be, with property taxes, insurance and any mortgage insurance inside it. The calculator on the hub does this with your own numbers and the tax rate for the school district you pick, and it puts a lender-style maximum next to your number so you can see your own gap.
Stress-test the number before you trust it
A comfortable payment should survive a bad month. Picture three months on one smaller paycheck, or a $5,000 repair in the first year, and ask yourself whether you'd get through it without new debt. In the Federal Reserve's latest survey of household finances, 55% of adults said they had three months of expenses set aside, so if you're not there yet, you've got plenty of company, and building that cushion is part of getting ready.⁵
It also helps to plan on some costs rising. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau warns that some home-related costs are likely to go up over time, and in Ohio a property tax bill can climb when the county updates values or voters approve a levy.² A number with a little room in it holds up better over the years than one that uses every dollar.
When spending closer to the approval can make sense
There are good reasons to go above a strictly comfortable number. A car loan that ends in a few months, a raise that's already in writing, or a second job that's been steady for years can all justify a bit more, as long as the payment still works on the income you have today. What I'd talk you out of is counting on a refinance, because nobody knows where rates will go, and a payment that only works after rates fall is a bet.
Where I come in, and where I stop
Once you have your number, I'll show you what it buys in the areas you like, with the actual property taxes and any association or community charges added in for each address. Questions and numbers are free, and you don't sign anything to get them. The approval itself is your lender's call, and I'll point you to one or two if you'd like a second Loan Estimate to compare. If you'd like a free, neutral look at your whole budget, a HUD-approved housing counselor can help with that.⁶
Questions people ask
Can I go over my pre-approval amount?
Usually not by much, because the approval is the lender's ceiling for your income and debts at today's rate. A bigger down payment, a lower rate or paying off a debt can raise it, and your lender can tell you exactly what would change it.
Is a pre-approval based on my take-home pay?
No. Lenders use your income before taxes, which is a big part of why an approval can look higher than what feels comfortable. Your comfortable number should start from what lands in your account.
What's a comfortable house payment?
It's the full payment, with taxes and insurance inside it, that still leaves room for your other bills, your savings and a cushion for surprises. There's no single percentage that fits everyone, so it's worth working out from your own month.
Will getting pre-approved hurt my credit?
A pre-approval usually includes a credit check. If you compare a few mortgage lenders, their credit checks within a 45-day window count as a single inquiry on your credit report, so shopping around doesn't multiply the effect.⁷
Find the payment that fits your month
Tell me roughly what you take home each month and what your month already costs, and I'll show you the payment that fits and what it buys in the places you're looking. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
The figures on this page are illustrations, not loan offers or advice. Your lender decides what you qualify for, and a CPA or tax adviser can answer questions about your own taxes.
Sources
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-02, Debt-to-Income Ratios, dated Apr 2, 2025 (36% for manually underwritten loans, up to 45% with credit score and reserve requirements, up to 50% through Desktop Underwriter). https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b3-6-02/debt-income-ratios (seen 2026-10-26). FHA, VA and USDA ceilings: HUD Mortgagee Letter 2026-11, Oct 8, 2026, https://www.hud.gov/sites/default/files/hudclips/documents/2026-11hsgml.pdf ; 38 CFR 36.4340, https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/38/36.4340 ; 7 CFR 3555.151, https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/7/3555.151 (seen 2026-10-26).
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, "How can I figure out if I can afford to buy a home and take out a mortgage?", last reviewed June 27, 2024 (quote, and "Some home-related costs are likely to rise over time"). https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/how-can-i-figure-out-if-i-can-afford-to-buy-a-home-and-take-out-a-mortgage-en-118/ (seen 2026-10-26)
- Take-home illustration, per month: gross wages $9,583, from $115,000 a year; 401(k) at 5%, $479; pre-tax health premium $350; federal income tax about $687, using the 2026 joint brackets and $32,200 standard deduction in IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32, https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-25-32.pdf (seen 2026-10-26); Social Security and Medicare at 7.65% of wages after the health premium, about $706; Ohio income tax about $172, at the 2026 flat 2.75% on income above $26,050 per EY Tax News, July 27, 2026, https://taxnews.ey.com/news/2026-1619-ohio-releases-modified-2026-income-tax-withholding-formulas-and-tables-reflecting-scheduled-tax-cut (seen 2026-10-26), after two $1,900 personal exemptions; Columbus income tax at 2.5%, about $231, City of Columbus Income Tax Division (seen 2026-10-26). Take-home about $6,957. Individual results vary with filing status, withholding and credits.
- Payment illustration: 30-year fixed loan at 7.24%, the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey average for the week of Oct 29, 2026, via FRED series MORTGAGE30US, https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MORTGAGE30US (seen 2026-11-05), a survey average and not an APR; on these assumptions, with no points or lender fees, an annual percentage rate of about 7.73%, because the mortgage insurance counts as a finance charge; 360 monthly payments, with mortgage insurance ending after about 12 years when the scheduled balance reaches 78% of the original price; 5% down; property tax at 1.8% of the price a year, close to the median of the tax year 2025 taxing district rates published by the Franklin, Union and Delaware County auditors; homeowners insurance at 0.52% of the price a year, scaled from NerdWallet's Columbus average of $2,065 a year for $400,000 of dwelling coverage, updated Mar 12, 2026; private mortgage insurance at 0.6% of the loan a year, inside Freddie Mac's typical range of $30 to $70 a month per $100,000 borrowed; repair fund 1% of the price a year, about $260 a month at $310,000; utilities $400 a month; debts of a $480 car payment and a $220 student loan payment, $700 in all; savings of $600 a month inside the $3,530. Comfortable payment: $6,957 take-home minus $3,530 and $400 leaves $3,027 for the house payment and repair fund, which supports a price of about $311,600 with a house payment of about $2,767. Lender-style: 45% or 50% of $9,583, minus $700 of debts. This is an illustration, not a loan offer. Your rate, APR and payment depend on your lender, credit and costs.
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2025, Savings and Investments, May 2026 ("55 percent of adults said they had set aside money for three months of expenses in an emergency savings or 'rainy day' fund"). https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/2026-economic-well-being-of-us-households-in-2025-savings-investments.htm (seen 2026-10-26)
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, find a HUD-approved housing counselor. https://www.consumerfinance.gov/find-a-housing-counselor/
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, "What happens when a mortgage lender checks my credit?", last reviewed Aug 28, 2026 ("Within a 45-day window, multiple credit checks from mortgage lenders are recorded on your credit report as a single inquiry"). https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/what-exactly-happens-when-a-mortgage-lender-checks-my-credit-en-2005/ (seen 2026-10-26)
Updated Nov 5, 2026.
