Skip to content
Aaron LeddyRed 1 RealtyREALTOR®

Rent or buy in Columbus in 2026?

Here's the math, house to house

By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated · 7-minute read

Tell me what you pay in rent, roughly what you take home and how long you'd like to stay, and I'll show you whether buying fits this year and what it would buy. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or run the calculator first

Maybe your renewal notice just came in a couple hundred dollars higher, or a friend who bought a house keeps telling you that rent is money down the drain. Whether to keep renting is a fair question, and it deserves real numbers. Nothing has to be decided before your lease is up, and one more lease while you get ready is a perfectly good outcome.

This guide puts a typical Columbus-area rental house next to owning a similar one, month by month and year by year, and shows when buying pulls ahead. It's part of my guide to what you can really afford. I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty, and if renting a while longer is the better move for you, I'll say so.

Compare a house with a house

Most rent figures you'll see mix apartments and houses, which makes renting look cheaper than it is for someone who wants a yard. In Zillow's index, the typical rent for all rentals in the Columbus metro was about $1,525 a month in September, while the typical single-family house rented for about $2,100.¹ If the place you'd buy is a house, that second figure is the fair one to compare against.

Why the first few years usually favor renting

Buying and selling a house costs money that renting doesn't, with closing costs when you buy and selling costs when you leave, and in the model below those add up to about 10% of the price over the round trip. The first years of a mortgage also go mostly to interest, so the loan balance comes down slowly at first. If you bought this house and sold it after three years, you'd likely end up about $27,000 behind a renter who invested what you put into the house, even with prices rising every year.³

So a short stay rarely pays for itself, and if there's a real chance you'll move for a job, for family or for more room within three to five years, renting usually leaves you with more money in the end.

When buying pulls ahead

The longer you stay, the more the math turns, because the payment on a fixed-rate loan stays put while rent keeps rising, and each payment chips away at a little more of the loan. Here's the year that owning first comes out ahead of renting in the same model, comparing the same house with a $2,100 rental whose rent rises 3% a year.³

If home prices rise each year by At this fall's average rate If rates were about 1.2 points lower
2% year 15 year 9
3% year 10 year 6
4% year 6 year 4

For reference, Zillow's forecast for Columbus-area home values was about 2% over the next year, and typical values rose a little over 1% in the year to September.¹ Nobody knows the next ten years, so the table shows a range, and none of it is a promise.

What the spreadsheet can't price

The math above assumes the renter actually invests the difference every month, and plenty of households don't, so the built-in saving of a mortgage payment counts for something. Owning also gets you a principal and interest payment that never goes up and the freedom to change the place without asking anyone. Renting keeps your cash free and the repair bills on someone else's desk, and you can leave when the lease is up. Those are real on both sides, and you're the one who gets to weigh them.

When the rent goes up again

A higher rent makes buying feel urgent, and it's a fine reason to start looking at the numbers, but on its own it isn't enough reason to buy a house whose payment doesn't fit. A rent increase is one more year of a bill you can walk away from, and a mortgage that's too big can follow you for years. It helps to treat renewing and buying as two separate decisions, and let your comfortable monthly number settle the second one.

If you keep renting for now

Another year of renting can be the start of a plan. An Ohio Homebuyer Plus account at a participating bank or credit union pays a boosted rate on money saved for a down payment, and contributions may be deductible from Ohio income tax.⁴ Paying down the debt with the biggest monthly payment, getting a lender's read on your credit and setting a date to run the numbers again will each move you closer. When the payment that fits your month and a house you'd want to live in finally meet, that's the time to buy, whatever the headlines say.

Where I come in, and where I stop

I'll put your rent next to what buying would cost you each month, show you what your comfortable number buys in the places you'd like to live, and if buying doesn't fit yet, show you what would change that. Questions and numbers are free, and you don't sign anything to get them. If the honest answer is another lease, I'll tell you, and I'll check back when the numbers move. Lease questions belong with your landlord or a tenant attorney, and the loan is your lender's call.

Questions people ask

Is renting throwing money away?

No more than paying mortgage interest, property taxes and insurance is. Rent buys you a place to live and the freedom to move, while the early years of a mortgage go mostly to interest, so the real questions are how long you'll stay and whether the payment fits.

How long do I need to stay for buying to make sense?

With this fall's numbers around Columbus, it usually takes about ten years on a typical house if prices rise about 3% a year, and less if prices climb faster or rates come down. If you might move within three to five years, renting usually comes out ahead.

Should I wait for rates to drop before buying?

Only if waiting makes sense for other reasons too. Nobody knows where rates will go, so if the payment fits your month today and you plan to stay, a lower rate later would be a bonus, and you'd want the house to work without it.

Can I compare renting and buying with my own numbers?

Yes. Start with the calculator on the what can I afford page to find the payment that fits your month, then compare it with your rent and how long you expect to stay.

Find out whether buying fits this year

Tell me what you pay in rent, roughly what you take home and how long you'd like to stay, and I'll show you whether buying fits this year and what it would buy. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or run the calculator first

The figures on this page are illustrations based on stated assumptions, not loan offers or predictions. Your lender decides what you qualify for, and a tenant attorney answers lease questions.

Sources

  1. Zillow Research data, Columbus, OH metro, downloaded 2026-10-26 from https://www.zillow.com/research/data/ (files at files.zillowstatic.com/research/public_csvs/). Zillow Observed Rent Index, all homes, smoothed, September 2026: $1,524.57, up 2.9% from $1,482.02 in September 2025. Zillow Observed Rent Index, single-family residences, September 2026: $2,107.94, up 4.8% from $2,011.44 a year earlier. Zillow Home Value Index, mid-tier, September 2026: $326,910, up 1.3% from $322,736. Zillow Home Value Forecast, base date Sept 30, 2026: 2.1% over the following 12 months.
  2. Payment illustration: $300,000 price, $15,000 down, $285,000 30-year fixed loan at 7.24%, the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey average for the week of Oct 29, 2026, via FRED series MORTGAGE30US, https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MORTGAGE30US (seen 2026-11-05), a survey average and not an APR. On these assumptions, with no points or lender fees, the annual percentage rate is about 7.73%, because the mortgage insurance counts as a finance charge. Repayment is 360 monthly payments, and the mortgage insurance ends after about 12 years, when the scheduled balance reaches 78% of the original price. Principal and interest $1,942.27; property tax $450 a month at 1.8% of the price a year, close to the median of the tax year 2025 district rates published by the Franklin, Union and Delaware County auditors; insurance $130 a month at 0.52% of the price a year, scaled from NerdWallet's Columbus average of $2,065 a year for $400,000 of dwelling coverage, updated Mar 12, 2026; private mortgage insurance $142.50 a month at 0.6% of the loan a year, inside Freddie Mac's typical range of $30 to $70 a month per $100,000 borrowed; repair fund $250 a month at 1% of the price a year. Full payment about $2,660 a month, or about $2,910 with the repair fund. Comparison rent: Zillow's single-family figure plus about $15 a month of renters insurance. This is an illustration, not a loan offer. Your rate, APR and payment depend on your lender, credit and costs.
  3. Rent-versus-buy model, run 2026-11-05. Owner: the loan in source 2; property tax rising 2% a year; insurance rising 4% a year; mortgage insurance until the scheduled balance reaches 78% of the price; repair fund at 1% of the home's current value a year; buying costs 3% of the price; selling costs 7% of the sale price; home value rising 2%, 3% or 4% a year. Renter: $2,100 a month plus $15 of renters insurance, rising 3% a year; invests the down payment and buying costs on day one, and each month's difference between owning and renting, at 4% a year. When renting costs more than owning, the owner invests the difference instead. The comparison is net worth: the owner's home value after selling costs, minus the loan balance, plus any investments, against the renter's investments. No tax effects. The table's two rate columns are 7.24% and 6.00%, which on the same assumptions are APRs of about 7.73% and 6.45%. Results at 3% appreciation and 7.24%: renter ahead by about $27,000 after three years and about $23,000 after five; owner ahead from year 10. With rent rising 4% a year instead of 3%, the break-even years are 12, 9 and 6 at 7.24%. With the renter's investments earning 6% a year instead of 4%, they are 20, 14 and 8. Against a $1,525 apartment rent, owning the $300,000 house doesn't come out ahead within 20 years at 2% or 3% appreciation, which is why the comparison above uses a house.
  4. Ohio Treasurer, Ohio Homebuyer Plus ("Contributions by the homebuyer, family members, or others may be tax deductible from the contributor's Ohio income tax"; current net premium interest rate 2.96%, updated quarterly; $100,000 maximum balance; use within five years for a down payment or closing costs on an Ohio home). https://tos.ohio.gov/homebuyerplus/ (seen 2026-10-26)

Updated Nov 5, 2026.

Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty

Aaron Leddy

Red 1 Realty

REALTOR®

(614) 578-5484

Brokered by

Red 1 Realty