Selling a rental with the tenant in place or vacant, and which one leaves you more in Central Ohio
By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated · 9-minute read
The short answer. Yes, you can sell a rental with the tenant still living there, and in Ohio the lease stays in place for the new owner. In a neighborhood where most homes are owner-occupied, though, a vacant house usually sells for more, because it reaches the buyers who plan to move in. Before you choose, price it both ways on the same day and compare what you'd actually keep.
Send the address, the rent and whether it's occupied. I'll show you what it would likely sell for with the tenant in place and vacant, and what you'd walk away with either way. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
Maybe your tenant just gave notice and you're wondering whether this is the moment to sell instead of finding the next one. Maybe the lease still has months to run, you're done now, and you'd like to know whether anyone will buy a house with a tenant living in it. Either way, wanting out is a fair reason to sell, and you can take a few weeks to decide how. This guide is one piece of how selling a rental works in Central Ohio, and it takes on the question most owners get stuck on first, which is whether to sell with the tenant in place or wait until the house is empty.
The answer depends on two prices that most people never see side by side, so that's where I'll start, and I'll finish with the case for keeping the house, because sometimes that's the better call.
Your rent sets one price and your street sets another
An investor looks at your house and starts with the rent. Many use a quick screen called the 1% rule, which says the monthly rent should be at least 1% of the purchase price, and even the ones who pay more than that are still pricing your house as an income property.¹ An owner-occupant looks at the same house and starts with what similar houses down the street sold for, because they're buying a place to live.
Here's how that plays out on a hypothetical three-bedroom rental on the west side that rents for $1,900 each month, where similar owner-occupied houses have been selling for about $300,000. These are my estimates for illustration, not a guarantee for any particular house.
| Sell with the tenant in place | Sell it vacant | |
|---|---|---|
| Likely price | $255,000 from an investor | $300,000 from an owner-occupant |
| Rent you give up while it sits empty | None | About $3,800 for two months |
| Paint, cleaning, small repairs and utilities | None | About $6,600 |
| What's left before selling costs and your loan payoff | About $255,000 | About $289,600 |
In this example, waiting until the house is empty leaves you about $35,000 more, even after the lost rent and the make-ready work, and the investor is already paying well past what the 1% screen allows. Selling costs come out of both columns, so they don't change the answer. On a lower-priced house where the rent is already close to 1% of its value, the two prices can land close together, which is why selling occupied often makes sense at the lower end of the market.
Who buys a house with a tenant in it
Most buyers can't. The standard Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac mortgage used in Ohio says the borrower will move in within 60 days of closing and live there for at least a year, unless the lender agrees otherwise.² A buyer with an owner-occupant loan generally can't close on a house with a lease running months past closing, so an occupied house mostly sells to investors and cash buyers.
Investors made up about 15% of Columbus home purchases in the first quarter of 2026, and the real share is a little higher, because that count only catches buyers using a company, LLC or trust name.³ If you sell with the tenant in place, your buyers come mostly from that slice of the market, and if you sell it vacant, you reach everyone else too, which is usually why the vacant price is higher in a neighborhood of owner-occupants.
What Ohio law says when you sell with a tenant
Selling the house doesn't end the lease. Ohio law treats the owner as the landlord, so the buyer steps into your shoes, and a tenant whose written lease runs past the closing gets to stay until it ends.⁴ Some leases have their own clause about a sale, so if yours does, have a landlord-tenant attorney read it.
If the tenant is month to month, either of you can end the tenancy with notice given at least 30 days before the next rent due date, and putting it in writing is the safe way to do it.⁵ While the house is for sale, the tenant can't unreasonably refuse to let you show it, and you have to give reasonable notice before you go in, with 24 hours presumed reasonable under Ohio law.⁶
The security deposit needs a plan too. Ohio's deposit law doesn't say what happens when the house sells, so it gets handled in the purchase contract and at closing, and the tenant should get a letter saying who holds it now.⁷ Ask your title agent how they handle it before you sign.
Two things are off the table no matter how frustrated you get. A landlord can't change the locks, shut off utilities or threaten a tenant to get them out without going through the courts, and you can't raise the rent, cut services or threaten an eviction because a tenant complained to the city about a code problem.⁸ Anything that heads toward an eviction belongs with a landlord-tenant attorney.
A timeline from today to a spring listing
Spring is usually the best time to sell around here. Columbus homes listed in the first two weeks of May have sold for about 3% more, roughly $9,000 on a $300,000 house.⁹ Here's how a month-to-month rental gets there, working backward from an early May listing.
- Now through December. Run both prices, talk to a CPA, and if the house is inside Columbus city limits, confirm your registration deadline with the city and register.
- By March 1, 2027. Give written notice so the tenancy ends before the April 1 rent date, or better yet, sign a voluntary move-out agreement before then.
- April 1. The tenant moves out, you do the walk-through, and the itemized deposit letter goes out within 30 days, as Ohio requires.⁷
- April. Paint, clean, fix what buyers will notice, and schedule photos once the yard greens up.
- First half of May. The house goes on the market.
If the tenant has a lease with a set end date, build the same schedule from that date instead. A lease that ends in late winter lines up nicely with spring, while one that runs through August is a reason to weigh selling occupied or keeping it another year.
If you'd like the tenant to move out sooner
Some owners offer a voluntary move-out agreement, which a lot of people call cash for keys. Done right, it's in writing, it's truly voluntary, you both sign it, and you pay only after the tenant has moved out, handed over the keys and you've walked through the house.¹⁰ It's separate from the security deposit, which still follows the normal rules.
Tell the tenant they're welcome to have a lawyer look at it, never set a deadline that sounds like a threat, and don't offer one to a tenant who just complained to code enforcement, because that can look like retaliation.⁸ Have a landlord-tenant attorney draft it.
The Columbus rental registry and your 2027 tax bill
If the house is inside Columbus, the city's new rental registry applies. City Council passed it in April 2026, and it charges $15 a unit each year and adds periodic inspections.¹¹ If you'll still own the house as a rental next year, confirm your registration deadline with the city's Building and Zoning Services department.
Property taxes are shifting too. In Franklin County, the every-three-years value update wraps up in December, and because Ohio bills property taxes a year behind, the new values show up on the bills you'll pay in 2027.¹² On those same bills, the state credit that rental homes still get starts shrinking, and it's scheduled to disappear by tax year 2029 while the credit for owner-occupied homes grows.¹³ If the rent barely covered the costs this year, run next year's numbers before you sign another lease.
Taxes to talk through with your CPA
Taxes on a rental sale depend on your whole return, so take these to a CPA before you pick a closing date.
- How much of my gain is depreciation? That part is taxed at up to 25% federally.¹⁴
- Will the net investment income tax apply? An extra 3.8% can apply to the gain once your income passes a threshold set by how you file.¹⁵
- How do Ohio and my city treat the gain? Ohio moved to a flat 2.75% rate on nonbusiness income above a set amount this year, and it's worth asking whether your city taxes the gain as well.¹⁶
- Does a 1031 exchange make sense? To trade into another investment property, the replacement has to be identified in writing within 45 days and received within 180 days, and it's usually done through a qualified intermediary, so talk to one before you close.¹⁷
- Do I still qualify for the home-sale exclusion? If you lived there for two of the five years before the sale, you might, so someone who moved out less than about three years ago could owe far less than they expect, though the rental-years depreciation still can't be excluded.¹⁸
When keeping it is the better call
I buy and renovate houses myself, and some rentals really are worth keeping. If the rent still covers everything after next year's tax bill, the tenant pays on time and takes care of the place, and what's really wearing you out is the phone calls, a property manager may fix that for less than selling would cost you.
Waiting can also beat selling now. If a good tenant's lease runs into the summer, collecting the rent and listing vacant the following spring often beats an investor's price today, and if your CPA says next year is a better tax year for the sale, that's reason enough to wait.
Two ways to sell, side by side
If the house is occupied and needs more work than you want to take on, there's another path. I can list it on the market, or get you an as-is cash number, and I'll show you both nets side by side. The cash number would come from Wright Home Offer, a company I co-own that buys houses as-is, and if it buys a rented house it takes on the lease and every protection your tenant has under Ohio law. If listing nets you more, I'll tell you to list.
I'm a licensed agent with Red 1 Realty, and I co-own Wright Home Offer. If you sell to Wright Home Offer, I'm on the buyer's side, not your agent, and the company expects to make a profit. You'll get this in writing to sign before we talk numbers, and you're welcome to have your own agent or attorney look at anything.
Who else you'll want on your side
You'll want a landlord-tenant attorney for the lease, any notice and any move-out agreement, and a CPA for the tax questions. I'll tell you when a question belongs with one of them.
Questions landlords ask
Can you sell a rental property with tenants in Ohio?
Yes. The lease stays in place, the buyer becomes the new landlord, and the tenant has to allow reasonable showings with notice. Most buyers for an occupied house are investors, which usually means a lower price in an owner-occupied neighborhood.
What happens to the security deposit when a rental is sold?
Ohio's deposit law doesn't address a sale, so it's handled in the purchase contract and at closing. Tell the tenant in writing who holds it now, and ask your title agent how they'll handle the transfer.
Should I sell my rental property or keep it?
Keep it if the numbers still work after next year's tax bill and your real problem is the management. Sell if the math no longer works or you want the money and time back, and compare both with the same numbers first.
Put both prices side by side
Send the address, the rent and whether it's occupied. I'll show you what it would likely sell for with the tenant in place and vacant, and what you'd walk away with either way. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
This guide is general information, not legal or tax advice.
Sources
- Freedom Mortgage, "What's the 1% Rule in Real Estate?" dated May 12, 2026 (rule: "the monthly rent for an investment property should be equal to or greater than 1% of the purchase price"; described as "most effective as an initial screening tool"). https://www.freedommortgage.com/learning-center/articles/1-rule-real-estate (seen 2026-10-25)
- Ohio Single Family Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac Uniform Instrument, Form 3036, Section 6, Occupancy ("Borrower shall occupy, establish, and use the Property as Borrower's principal residence within 60 days after the execution of this Security Instrument and shall continue to occupy the Property as Borrower's principal residence for at least one year after the date of occupancy, unless Lender otherwise agrees in writing"), from the copy filed with the Ohio House Civil Justice Committee, March 22, 2022. https://search-prod.lis.state.oh.us/api/v2/general_assembly_134/committees/cmte_h_civil_justice_1/meetings/cmte_h_civil_justice_1_2022-03-22-0200_1286/submissions/mortgage.pdf (seen 2026-10-25). The current Form 3036 is dated 07/2021 per FHFA: https://www.fhfa.gov/mortgage-translations/document/form-3036-ohio-mortgage (seen 2026-10-25). Secondary summary of the same rule, Homebuyer.com, Feb 24, 2026: https://homebuyer.com/guidelines/fannie-mae/occupancy-types-b2-1-1-01 (seen 2026-10-25)
- Redfin, "Investor Home Purchases Fall to Lowest Level Since 2020," Q1 2026, published May 28, 2026 (Columbus: 15% investor share, 637 homes, down 14% year over year; investors identified by buyer names containing LLC, Inc, Trust, Corp or Homes, or by deed ownership codes). https://www.redfin.com/news/investor-report-q1-2026/ (seen 2026-10-25)
- Ohio Revised Code 5321.01, definitions, effective Oct 3, 2023 ("Landlord" means "the owner, lessor, or sublessor of residential premises"). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-5321.01 (seen 2026-10-25). Ruzicho Law, Ohio eviction attorney, "Selling rental unit, can I evict current tenants?" ("If the current tenants are on a written lease that expires sometime after the sale/transfer of property, the new owner has to honor the lease"). https://ruzicholaw.com/eviction-law/common-eviction-questions-and-answers/selling-rental-unit-can-i-evict-current-tenants/ (seen 2026-10-25)
- Ohio Revised Code 5321.17(B), effective Aug 22, 1990 (a month-to-month tenancy may be ended "by notice given the other at least thirty days prior to the periodic rental date"; the section doesn't say the notice must be written, so writing is recommended practice, not a statutory requirement). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-5321.17 (seen 2026-10-25)
- Ohio Revised Code 5321.05(B), effective Aug 22, 1990 (tenant "shall not unreasonably withhold consent for the landlord to enter" to "exhibit the dwelling unit to prospective or actual purchasers"). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-5321.05 . Ohio Revised Code 5321.04(A)(8), effective Sept 28, 2012 ("Twenty-four hours is presumed to be a reasonable notice in the absence of evidence to the contrary"). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-5321.04 (both seen 2026-10-25)
- Ohio Revised Code 5321.16, effective Nov 4, 1974 (itemized written notice and any balance due "within thirty days after termination of the rental agreement and delivery of possession"; 5% annual interest on the excess over the greater of $50 or one month's rent once the tenant has stayed six months; the section does not address a sale of the property). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-5321.16 (seen 2026-10-25)
- Ohio Revised Code 5321.15, effective Nov 4, 1974 (no "termination of utilities or services, exclusion from the premises, or threat of any unlawful act" to recover possession outside the courts). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-5321.15 . Ohio Revised Code 5321.02, effective Nov 4, 1974 (no "increasing the tenant's rent, decreasing services that are due to the tenant, or bringing or threatening to bring an action for possession" in retaliation for a code complaint). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-5321.02 (both seen 2026-10-25)
- Zillow, "Best time to list: Homes sell for $6,000 more in late May," March 18, 2026 (Columbus, OH: best listing window the first two weeks of May, 3.1% premium). https://zillow.mediaroom.com/2026-03-18-Best-time-to-list-Homes-sell-for-6,000-more-in-late-May (seen 2026-10-25). The $9,000 figure is 3.1% of the example's $300,000 price.
- TurboTenant, "Cash for Keys Agreement: What Landlords Need to Know," updated Sept 17, 2026 (use a signed written agreement; consent must be voluntary; inspect and collect keys before paying). https://www.turbotenant.com/property-management/cash-for-keys/ (seen 2026-10-25)
- Scioto Title, "Columbus City Council Passes Rental Registry and Property Inspection Ordinance," Apr 25, 2026 (passed Apr 20, 2026; "$15 per unit, capped at $1,500 per complex"; inspections every three years; Columbus City Code Chapter 4515). https://www.sciototitle.com/scioto-blog/columbus-city-council-passes-rental-registry-and-property-inspection-ordinance . ABC6, Apr 21, 2026: https://abc6onyourside.com/news/local/city-council-votes-to-pass-bill-creating-registry-of-residential-rental-properties-columbus-ohio-housing-crisis . (both seen 2026-10-25)
- Franklin County Auditor, 2026 Triennial Property Value Update guide ("December 2026: Property values finalized"). https://auditor.franklincountyohio.gov/files/assets/auditor/v/1/documents/real-estate/kyhv/2026-triennial-guide.pdf . Delaware County Auditor, reappraisal page ("In Ohio we pay taxes one year in arrears"). https://auditor.co.delaware.oh.us/2024-reappraisal-draft/ (both seen 2026-10-25)
- Delaware County Auditor, statement on Ohio property tax reform, Jan 16, 2026 ("For tax year 2026 tax bills, the nonbusiness credit will be reduced to 7.5% and the owner-occupancy credit will be increased to 5.7%"; full phase-out of the nonbusiness credit "with the tax bills for tax year 2029 when the owner-occupancy credit increases to 15.38%"). https://co.delaware.oh.us/2026/01/16/statement-from-the-delaware-county-auditor-on-ohio-property-tax-reform/ . Tucker Ellis, "Four New Ohio Property Tax Laws," January 2026 (HB 186). https://www.tuckerellis.com/alerts/four-new-ohio-property-tax-laws-what-they-mean-for-residential-and-commercial-owners/ (both seen 2026-10-25)
- IRS Tax Topic 409, Capital gains and losses, updated Sept 24, 2026 ("The portion of any unrecaptured section 1250 gain from selling section 1250 real property is taxed at a maximum 25% rate"). https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc409 (seen 2026-10-25)
- IRS Tax Topic 559, Net investment income tax, updated Sept 24, 2026 (3.8%; thresholds $250,000 married filing jointly, $125,000 married filing separately, $200,000 single or head of household; includes net gains from real estate and rents unless from an active business). https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc559 (seen 2026-10-25)
- Tax Foundation, "2026 State Tax Changes Taking Effect January 1st," Dec 18, 2025, updated Jan 6, 2026 ("flat rate of 2.75 percent for all nonbusiness income over $26,050," HB 96). https://taxfoundation.org/research/all/state/2026-state-tax-changes/ (seen 2026-10-25). Whether a given city taxes the gain is unverified here and is a CPA question.
- IRS, Instructions for Form 8824 (2025) (replacement property "must be identified within 45 days" and "received within 180 days, or by the due date of your tax return (including extensions), whichever is earlier"; deferred exchanges through a qualified intermediary). https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/i8824.pdf (seen 2026-10-25)
- IRS Tax Topic 701, Sale of your home, updated Oct 12, 2026 (ownership and use for at least 24 months of the last 5 years; up to $250,000, or $500,000 joint). https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc701 . IRS Publication 523 (2025) ("You can't exclude the portion of gain equal to any section 1250(b)(3) depreciation adjustments allowed or allowable after May 6, 1997"). https://www.irs.gov/publications/p523 (both seen 2026-10-25)
The worked example's prices, rent, lost rent and make-ready costs are hypothetical estimates for illustration, prepared Oct 25, 2026.
