Skip to content
Aaron LeddyRed 1 RealtyREALTOR®

Keep your old house as a rental or sell it?

What lenders count since September 2026

By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated · 8-minute read

The short answer. Keep it only if the full monthly math still works when a lender counts just 75% of the market rent, and only if you actually want to be a landlord. If the numbers don't work, or you don't want the job, selling usually funds the next house better, and staying put and adding space is a real third option worth pricing.

Tell me what you're selling and what you'd like to buy, and I'll map out the order that fits, with both monthly numbers side by side. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or see what your house would sell for first.

Maybe you've found the bigger house, or you're close, and everyone from your brother-in-law to the posts in your feed says never give up a 3% rate, just keep the old place as a rental. That advice sounds smart until you run it on your own house, and you're allowed to want real numbers before you decide anything. This guide is part of selling one house and buying the next, and it covers what lenders count now, what Ohio's property tax changes do to a house that becomes a rental, and the full monthly math on a typical Central Ohio house.

I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty. I buy and renovate houses myself, so I'm all for owning real estate when it works, and I'd like you to choose being a landlord on purpose instead of by default.

Why keeping it is so tempting

The pull is real, because trading your old loan for a new one at today's rates can change your budget by hundreds of dollars a month.

What lenders count now

If you'd like to use rent from the old house to help you qualify for the new loan, the rules changed on September 2, 2026, for conventional loans that follow Fannie Mae's guide.² A signed lease no longer counts as proof of the rent. Instead, the lender gets market rent from an appraisal or from comparable rentals nearby, counts 75% of it and subtracts the old house's full monthly payment, including taxes and insurance. In plain terms, the lender assumes a quarter of the rent goes to empty months and upkeep, and if the full payment is more than the other three-quarters, the difference counts against you as debt.

There's a second rule for first-time landlords. If you have less than a year of experience managing rentals, you'll need six months of the old house's full payment set aside in reserves. And if you're thinking about buying first and deciding later, lenders generally count both payments unless the old house is already under contract and the buyer's financing contingencies have cleared.³

Where the down payment comes from

If most of your savings is the equity in the house you're leaving, keeping that house means the down payment has to come from somewhere else, usually savings or a home equity line on the old house. A home equity line has its own payment, and once the house is a rental, that payment is part of what it costs you each month. If there's any chance you'll end up selling instead, open the line before you list, because many lenders won't open one on a house that's for sale.⁴ Talk to a lender before you decide anything, since the order you do things in decides which options you have.

What a rental costs that a home doesn't

Ohio's property tax credit for owner-occupied homes is growing in steps until it reaches 15.38% in tax year 2029, while the credit that rentals still get is being phased out over the same years.⁵ A house that becomes a rental loses the first once it's no longer your home and the second by 2029, so its bill climbs faster than your neighbor's. The owner-occupancy credit only applies to levies voters approved in 2013 or earlier, so the dollar difference is smaller than the percentage suggests, and the county auditor can show you the real figure for your parcel.⁶ You also have to tell the auditor when the house stops being your home, because if you don't, the county can charge back the credit with interest.⁷

Inside Columbus, a rental also has to be registered with the city at $15 a unit each year under the registry City Council passed in April 2026, so confirm when your registration is due, and the county auditor can require you to register it there too.⁸

The full monthly math on a typical house

Here's a hypothetical house, bought in 2021 with a $240,000 loan at 3%, now worth about $320,000 and likely to rent for about $2,100 a month. Every figure is my estimate for illustration, not a guarantee and not a loan offer.

Each month Hypothetical
Rent $2,100
Full payment, with principal, interest, taxes and landlord insurance -$1,537
Repairs at about 1% of the value a year, plus one empty month a year -$442
Higher property tax without the owner-occupancy credit, plus the Columbus registry fee -$20
Left over before a property manager and income taxes About $100

That's about $100 a month, or roughly $1,200 a year, for being on call for every furnace and every turnover, and one roof or sewer line can wipe out several years of it. By the lender's math, the rent barely covers the payment, so you'd qualify with almost no cushion, and as a first-time landlord you'd also need about $9,200 in reserves. If you hire a property manager, the monthly margin likely disappears.

Taxes when you eventually sell

The home-sale exclusion lets you skip federal tax on a large share of your gain if you owned and lived in the house for two of the five years before the sale.⁹ So once you move out and rent it, you generally have about three years to sell and still qualify. The catch is depreciation. Any depreciation you were allowed to take on the rental can't be excluded, even if you never claimed it, and that part of the gain is taxed at up to 25% federally.¹⁰ Put the three-year date on your calendar the day you move out, and talk to a CPA before you sign a lease.

Two other ways to get more room

Sell and use the equity. Selling turns the equity into your down payment, keeps you to one mortgage and lets you skip the landlord work entirely.

In September, about 13% fewer Central Ohio homes went under contract than a year earlier.¹¹ When fewer buyers are competing, a buyer who has a house to sell has more room to ask for an offer that depends on that sale.

Stay and add the space. Finishing a basement or adding a bedroom keeps your rate. If the project costs less than the payment gap over the next five years or so, staying is often the better money answer, and it's worth getting a contractor's number before you decide anything else.

When keeping it works

Keeping the old house can work when the rent covers the full payment with room to spare, even after the lender's discount, and you have the reserves without draining your emergency fund. It also helps if the roof, furnace and water heater have years left and you plan to hold the house well past the three-year window, and it's easier still if you like fixing things or don't mind paying someone who does. If you're torn, it's fine to wait on the decision while you price all three paths side by side, because the right answer usually gets clearer once the numbers sit next to each other.

Questions people ask

Should I keep my house as a rental or sell it?

Keep it if the full monthly math works with room to spare, you have the reserves and you actually want to be a landlord. Otherwise, selling usually funds the next house better, and adding space to the house you have is worth pricing too.

Can I use rent from my current house to qualify for a new mortgage?

Often, yes, but on a conventional loan that follows Fannie Mae's guide, a lease no longer counts as proof. The lender uses market rent, counts 75% of it against the full payment, and may require six months of reserves if you've never been a landlord.

Can you buy a house before selling yours?

Yes, if you can qualify with both payments or have a home equity line or bridge loan in place. Lenders generally count both payments unless your current house is under contract with the buyer's financing contingencies cleared, so talk to a lender before you start touring.

How long can I rent out my old house and still use the home-sale exclusion?

Generally about three years after you move out, since the rule looks for two years of living there in the five years before the sale. Depreciation from the rental years is still taxed, so check your dates with a CPA.

Do I have to register my house as a rental?

Inside Columbus, yes, with the city's rental registry, and the county auditor can require registration too. You also need to tell the auditor the house is no longer owner-occupied so the credit comes off correctly.

Put moving and staying side by side

Tell me what you're selling and what you'd like to buy, and I'll map out the order that fits, with both monthly numbers side by side. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or see what your house would sell for first.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or lending advice. Your lender's Loan Estimate is the real number for any loan, and a CPA handles the tax side.

Sources

  1. Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, 30-year fixed average 7.24% for the week of Oct 29, 2026. https://www.freddiemac.com/pmms . Principal and interest per $100,000 on a 30-year fixed loan: about $422 at 3% and about $681 at 7.24%, a difference of about $260, before taxes and insurance. 7.24% is Freddie Mac's weekly average, not an APR. With no points, fees or mortgage insurance assumed, those are also APRs of 3% and 7.24%. This is an illustration, not a loan offer. Your rate, APR and payment depend on your lender, credit and costs.
  2. Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-3.8-05, Rental Income from Non-Subject Property: Departing Residence, dated 09/02/2026 ("Lease agreements are not permitted for any departing residence"; market rent from an appraisal, Form 1007, or a market analysis with at least three comparable rentals; "Multiply the monthly gross rent(s) by 75%" and subtract the departing residence's PITIA; borrowers with less than 12 months of property management experience need "six months of reserves to cover the PITIA obligation for the vacated property"). https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b3-3.8-05/rental-income-non-subject-property-departing-residence (seen 2026-10-25)
  3. Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-06, Qualifying Impact of Other Real Estate Owned, dated 09/02/2026 (current and proposed PITIA both used unless the lender has "the executed sales contract for the current residence, and confirmation that any financing contingencies have been cleared"). https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b3-6-06/qualifying-impact-other-real-estate-owned (seen 2026-10-25)
  4. Lendmire (NMLS 2371349), "Open a HELOC Before Listing," Oct 15, 2026 ("No law says a lender must refuse a listed home. It is a lender policy, and policies differ"; in six states Lendmire serves, homes listed for sale or listed in the past 60 days are ineligible). https://www.lendmire.com/open-a-heloc-before-listing/ (seen 2026-10-25). One lender's published policy, not a rule for every lender.
  5. Delaware County Auditor, statement on Ohio property tax reform, Jan 16, 2026 ("For tax year 2026 tax bills, the nonbusiness credit will be reduced to 7.5% and the owner-occupancy credit will be increased to 5.7%"; the nonbusiness credit is fully phased out "with the tax bills for tax year 2029 when the owner-occupancy credit increases to 15.38%"). https://co.delaware.oh.us/2026/01/16/statement-from-the-delaware-county-auditor-on-ohio-property-tax-reform/ . Tucker Ellis, "Four New Ohio Property Tax Laws," January 2026 (HB 186 raises the owner-occupied rollback "from the current 2.5% to 15.38% by 2029 while phasing out the 10% rollback on non-business residential property"). https://www.tuckerellis.com/alerts/four-new-ohio-property-tax-laws-what-they-mean-for-residential-and-commercial-owners/ (both seen 2026-10-25)
  6. Franklin County Auditor, Tax Reduction Programs (the owner-occupancy credit "applies only to tax levies passed during or prior to the November 2013 general election"). https://auditor.franklincountyohio.gov/Real-Estate/Tax-Reduction-Programs (seen 2026-10-25)
  7. Ohio Revised Code 323.153, effective Sept 30, 2025 (the owner "shall notify the county auditor" when no longer qualified; otherwise "a charge shall be imposed against the property in the amount by which taxes were reduced," with interest). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-323.153 (seen 2026-10-25)
  8. Scioto Title, "Columbus City Council Passes Rental Registry and Property Inspection Ordinance," Apr 25, 2026 (passed Apr 20, 2026; "$15 per unit, capped at $1,500 per complex"). https://www.sciototitle.com/scioto-blog/columbus-city-council-passes-rental-registry-and-property-inspection-ordinance . Ohio Revised Code 5323.02, effective Sept 30, 2025 ("An owner of residential rental property shall file with the county auditor"). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-5323.02 (both seen 2026-10-25)
  9. IRS Tax Topic 701, Sale of your home, updated Oct 12, 2026 (ownership and use for at least 24 months of the last 5 years; exclude up to $250,000, or $500,000 on a joint return). https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc701 (seen 2026-10-25)
  10. IRS Publication 523 (2025) ("You can't exclude the portion of gain equal to any section 1250(b)(3) depreciation adjustments allowed or allowable after May 6, 1997"). https://www.irs.gov/publications/p523 . IRS Tax Topic 409, updated Sept 24, 2026 (unrecaptured section 1250 gain "is taxed at a maximum 25% rate"). https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc409 (both seen 2026-10-25)
  11. Columbus REALTORS, Central Ohio Housing Report, September 2026, published Oct 13, 2026 (homes under contract down 12.7% from a year earlier). https://columbusrealtors.com/news/central-ohio-housing-reports---september-2026

The worked example is hypothetical, prepared Oct 25, 2026. Its assumptions: a $240,000, 30-year loan at 3%, about $1,012 a month in principal and interest; property taxes of $5,000 a year; landlord insurance of $1,300 a year; value of $320,000; rent of $2,100; repairs at 1% of value a year; one vacant month a year; $20 a month for the lost owner-occupancy credit and the city fee, an estimate that your own tax bill will replace. The lender figures use 75% of $2,100, or $1,575, against a $1,537 full payment, and six months of that payment, about $9,200, for reserves. This is an illustration, not a loan offer.

Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty

Aaron Leddy

Red 1 Realty

REALTOR®

(614) 578-5484

Brokered by

Red 1 Realty