Skip to content
Aaron LeddyRed 1 RealtyREALTOR®

Your company's buyout offer or listing it yourself, and how to tell which nets more

By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated · 9-minute read

The short answer. Treat your company's buyout as the floor and its marketing window as the clock. Then compare it with what a listing would likely leave you on the same date, after any costs the program would have paid. If listing doesn't clearly beat the buyout inside the window, taking the certainty is a perfectly reasonable choice.

Tell me the date you need to be there. I'll work backward from it and show you what selling on time looks like, including selling after you've already moved. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Moving here instead? Start here.

Maybe the offer letter came faster than you expected, and now there's a start date in another city and a house here that still has to sell. If your employer offers relocation help, you probably also have a policy full of terms like guaranteed buyout and buyer value option, and a relocation company asking you to choose an agent from its list. You don't have to master all of it this week, but it's worth understanding before you sign a listing agreement, because the policy shapes both your price and your timeline.

This guide is one part of moving for work with a house to sell, and it explains how these programs usually work from the seller's side and how to tell whether the buyout or a listing leaves you more. I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty, and the first thing I'd ask you for is a copy of your policy.

Read your policy before you call anyone, me included

Programs differ a lot from one employer to the next, so your own policy is the one that counts, and nothing here describes any particular company's benefit. Look for these four things first:

  • Whether you have to use an agent from the relocation company's network.
  • Any rule about how your list price is set, since programs commonly order broker market analyses and may tie your list price to them.¹
  • The buyout terms, if there is a buyout, including how the value is set and how long you have to market the house.
  • Any bonus for finding your own buyer, which some programs pay because a quick sale saves them money.²

If anything is unclear, ask the relocation company to answer in writing before you list.

How a guaranteed buyout works

In a typical guaranteed buyout, the relocation company orders two appraisals that follow Worldwide ERC's relocation appraisal standards, and those appraisals set the price the company will pay you.² You then get a marketing period, usually 60 or 90 days, to sell on the open market, and if the house hasn't sold by the end, the company buys it at that value and takes over the costs of owning it. Because that puts more risk on the employer, it's usually reserved for senior roles, so don't be surprised if your policy doesn't include one.² For you, the appraised value is a floor you know about in advance, and the marketing period is your deadline for beating it.

How a buyer value option works

In a buyer value option, you list the house and find the buyer. Once you have an acceptable outside offer, the relocation company buys the house from you based on that offer and then sells it to your buyer, so there are two separate sales.¹ Companies set it up that way so the selling costs they cover aren't treated as taxable pay to you, which they would be if the company simply reimbursed you, and they rely on an IRS ruling about similar programs to do it.³ So the price is only as good as the offer you bring in, so pricing and presentation matter just as much as they would in any other sale.

Compare them on the same date

The comparison only works when both numbers are measured the same way, on the same day, against the same loan payoff. Here's how it looks on a hypothetical house where the guaranteed buyout came in at $340,000 and you're weighing it against listing the house on your own, outside the program. These are my estimates for illustration, not a guarantee.

Take the buyout List it on your own
Price $340,000 About $360,000, priced for the first two weekends
Selling costs Paid by the program About $22,000, paid by you
What's left before your loan payoff $340,000 About $338,000

In this example, the higher price doesn't survive the costs the program would have paid, and every month the house sits past the date the company would have bought it adds roughly $2,500 in payments, utilities and insurance. The math flips when the buyout comes in low, or when your policy lets you sell to your own buyer inside the program with the costs still covered, because then a higher price goes straight to you.

Pricing for the window

On a deadline, the bigger cost is the weeks a price cut takes,⁴ so price it for the first two weekends, while it's new to every buyer who's been watching.

If showings are slow, a credit the buyer can use toward a lower interest rate often does more than a price cut of the same size, because a temporary buydown lowers the buyer's first-year payment by several times what the same money off the price would.⁵ Buyers feel today's rates in the monthly payment, so that kind of credit can bring an offer without a cut, as long as it fits the seller-credit limits on the buyer's loan.

Leaving before it sells

If you move before the house sells, call your insurance agent first. A standard homeowners policy can stop covering vandalism and frozen pipes once a house has sat vacant for 60 days in a row, so ask about a vacancy endorsement and keep the heat on all winter.⁶

You probably won't have to fly back to close, either. Ohio lets an Ohio notary notarize documents online for a signer anywhere in the United States, though the title company and the buyer's lender decide whether they'll accept it.⁷ If someone will sign for you under a power of attorney instead, Ohio requires it to be recorded with the county recorder before the deed, so set that up with the title company early.⁸

Taxes to ask a CPA about

If you've owned and lived in the house less than two years, you may still get part of the home-sale exclusion when the new job is at least 50 miles farther from the house than your old job was.⁹ Moving expenses also aren't deductible for most people anymore, and moving money your employer pays you now counts as taxable wages, so ask whether your package includes a tax gross-up.¹⁰ Bring your dates and your policy to a CPA before you pick a closing date.

When the buyout or renting it out is the smarter move

If the gap between the buyout and a likely listing net is only a few thousand dollars, taking the certainty is a reasonable choice, and I'll tell you that. You'll move with one less thing to manage from another state.

Renting the house can make sense if the assignment is temporary, your rate is low and the rent covers the full cost with room to spare. It comes with landlord work from a distance, the loss of Ohio's owner-occupancy tax credit and a three-year clock on the home-sale exclusion, and all of it is worth pricing out before you sign a lease.

All the nets, side by side

When the date is tight, one more option is worth seeing. I can list it on the market, or get you an as-is cash number, and I'll show you both nets side by side, next to any buyout your company offers. The cash number would come from Wright Home Offer, a company I co-own, and before it's named as a buyer, I'd ask your relocation company whether its policy allows a sale to a company connected to your agent. It's a choice you'd make up front instead of listing, never a promise to buy if the listing doesn't sell, and if listing nets you more, I'll tell you to list.

I'm a licensed agent with Red 1 Realty, and I co-own Wright Home Offer. If you sell to Wright Home Offer, I'm on the buyer's side, not your agent, and the company expects to make a profit. You'll get this in writing to sign before we talk numbers, and you're welcome to have your own agent or attorney look at anything.

Where I come in

I'll start with your policy and your date, then work backward to a list date, a price and a plan for the house after you leave, including lockbox showings and remote signing through the title company. Your company's policy decides what's covered, the relocation company answers questions about the program, and a CPA handles the tax side.

Questions people ask

How does a relocation home sale work?

Home sale programs commonly work one of two ways. The company either guarantees to buy your house at an appraised value if it doesn't sell within a marketing window, or it buys the house from you at the price an outside buyer offers and then resells it to that buyer. Your employer's policy decides which one you have and what it covers.

Will a relocation company buy my house?

If your policy includes a guaranteed buyout, yes, at the appraised value once the marketing period ends without a sale. Some policies offer only the buyer value option, where the company buys only after you've found a buyer.

Can I sell my house in Ohio after I've moved out of state?

Yes. Ohio allows online notarization for signers anywhere in the U.S., though the title company and the buyer's lender set their own rules, and a power of attorney has to be recorded before the deed. Call your insurance agent about vacancy coverage the week you move out.

Do I owe taxes if I sell before two years because of a job move?

Possibly, though a new job at least 50 miles farther from the house than your old one can qualify you for a partial exclusion. Bring your dates to a CPA before you choose a closing date.

Is a relocation buyout better than listing?

Sometimes. Compare the buyout with a likely listing net on the same date, after any costs the program would have covered, and remember that your policy may set rules on how you list.

Start from your start date

Tell me the date you need to be there. I'll work backward from it and show you what selling on time looks like, including selling after you've already moved. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Moving here instead? Start here.

This guide is general information, not legal or tax advice. Your company's relocation policy decides what's covered, and a CPA handles the tax side.

Sources

  1. North American Van Lines, "Ultimate Guide to Home Sale Programs," undated (describes the "Guaranteed Buy-Out/Appraised Value Offer" and the "Buyer Value Option," in which "the relocation provider extends an offer to buy the relocating employee's existing home based on an outside offer the employee has already received from a buyer," and lists "BMA and List Price Accuracy" among program measures). https://www.northamerican.com/corporate-relocation/resources/guides/ultimate-guide-to-home-sale-programs (seen 2026-10-25). A specific list-price cap was not stated on the page and is unverified.
  2. Aires, "The Basics of a Guaranteed Buyout," Aug 20, 2020 (two Worldwide ERC Relocation Appraisals set fair market value; marketing period typically 60 or 90 days; the relocation company handles carrying costs after the period ends; a home sale bonus can speed the sale; the program carries more inventory risk and cost than a buyer value option and is typically used for executive-level moves). https://blog.aires.com/the-basics-of-a-guaranteed-buyout (seen 2026-10-25)
  3. Aires, "The Basics of a Buyer Value Option," Aug 18, 2017 (a formal program with "two separate and independent home sales"; favorable tax treatment relies on IRS Rev. Rul. 2005-74 for similar amended value programs; direct reimbursement creates taxable income). https://blog.aires.com/the-basics-of-a-buyer-value-option (seen 2026-10-25)
  4. Columbus REALTORS, Central Ohio Housing Report, September 2026, published Oct 13, 2026 (sellers received 96.3% of their original list price and 98.8% of their final list price). https://columbusrealtors.com/news/central-ohio-housing-reports---september-2026
  5. A 2-1 temporary buydown lowers the rate two points in year one and one point in year two, so its first-year savings run several times the payment change from taking the same money off the price. Seller-funded buydowns count toward the loan's interested-party contribution limits, per Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02, dated May 7, 2025. https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b3-4.1-02/interested-party-contributions-ipcs (seen 2026-10-25)
  6. Insure Financial Services, "You Should Know: Homeowners Policy, Vacancy Exclusion," undated (vandalism and freezing of plumbing not covered once a building has been vacant 60 consecutive days; coverage for freezing may still apply if the insured used reasonable care to maintain heat). https://insureohio.com/you-should-know-homeowners-policy-vacancy-exclusion (seen 2026-10-25)
  7. Ohio Revised Code 147.64, effective Sept 20, 2019 (an online notary must be an Ohio resident located in Ohio at the time of the notarization and may serve principals located anywhere in the United States). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-147.64 (seen 2026-10-25)
  8. Ohio Revised Code 1337.04(C), effective Oct 24, 2024 ("A power of attorney used for the execution of a real property instrument shall be recorded in the office of the county recorder ... before the recording of the real property instrument executed by virtue of such power of attorney"). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-1337.04 (seen 2026-10-25)
  9. IRS Publication 523 (2025), partial exclusion when "You took or were transferred to a new job in a work location at least 50 miles farther from the home than your old work location." https://www.irs.gov/publications/p523 (seen 2026-10-25)
  10. Foster Garvey, Larry J. Brant, "One Big Beautiful Bill Act, Part 8: Worker Moving Expenses," Mar 10, 2026 (the suspension of the moving expense deduction and of the exclusion for employer reimbursements is now permanent, except for members of the Armed Forces and, newly, the intelligence community; reimbursed amounts are included in wages on Form W-2). https://www.foster.com/newsroom/blog/larrys-tax-law/one-big-beautiful-bill-act-part-8-worker-moving-expenses/ (seen 2026-10-25)

The buyout comparison is hypothetical, prepared Oct 25, 2026: a $340,000 buyout, a $360,000 sale on your own, about $22,000 in selling costs you'd pay outside the program, and about $2,500 in monthly carrying costs for the payment, utilities and insurance. Your own policy, price and costs will differ.

Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty

Aaron Leddy

Red 1 Realty

REALTOR®

(614) 578-5484

Brokered by

Red 1 Realty