Skip to content
Aaron LeddyRed 1 RealtyREALTOR®

Cash offer or listing? How to check any as-is offer against what the market would pay

By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated · 9-minute read

The short answer. Sometimes a cash offer really is the better deal, usually when there's a hard deadline, a lot of repairs or no way to keep paying for the house while it sells. The only fair way to know is to put the cash offer and a listing side by side on the same date, with the same loan payoff and the same facts about the house, and compare what you'd actually walk away with.

Send the address and a few phone photos of the rough spots, and I'll put the numbers side by side for your house. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or read how to decide what to fix before you sell.

Maybe a company has offered to buy the house as-is, and the number is lower than you hoped, but skipping repairs and showings sounds like a relief. Maybe it's your dad's house, the roof is near the end and nobody in the family has the time or money to fix it. You don't have to say yes or no to anyone this week, and you can check any offer yourself once you know how the buyer got to it.

This page shows how investors price a house, the middle option that often gets skipped, and how to set all three choices side by side. If you're still deciding what to fix, start with my guide on whether to fix it up or sell it as-is.

Where I stand, before you read any further. If listing nets you more, I'll tell you to list.

I'm a licensed agent with Red 1 Realty, and I co-own Wright Home Offer. If you sell to Wright Home Offer, I'm on the buyer's side, not your agent, and the company expects to make a profit. You'll get this in writing to sign before we talk numbers, and you're welcome to have your own agent or attorney look at anything.

How an investor prices a house that needs work

Most investors start from what the house would sell for after it's fixed up, which they call the after-repair value, and work backward. They subtract the repairs, the cost of holding the house while the work gets done and the cost of selling it again, and whatever's left has to include their profit, so every cushion they build in for surprises comes out of your price.

Many investors screen a house with what they call the 70% rule, taking 70% of the after-repair value and subtracting the repairs to get roughly the most they'd pay.¹ The lender Kiavi calls it a quick screening tool that investors adjust for their market and the profit they want, so use it to understand an offer, and don't mistake it for a fair price. Here it is on a made-up house.

Made-up example Amount
What it would sell for after a full update $300,000
70% of that $210,000
Minus the repairs the investor estimates $50,000
Screening number, about the most they'd offer $160,000

The 30% off the top covers the investor's holding, financing and selling costs, the risk of overruns and their margin. You can run the same math on your own house, and if an offer lands far below that screening number, the buyer is either expecting more repairs than you are or building in a bigger cushion, and you're entitled to ask which.

The middle option, listing it as-is on the open market

Between fixing everything and taking a private cash offer, there's a third choice, which is listing the house as it is, priced for its condition, so investors and buyers who want a project can bid against each other. Investors bought about 15% of the homes sold in the Columbus area in the first quarter of 2026,² so a fairly priced fixer usually draws more than one of them, and competition is what pushes a price above any single buyer's screening number.

Flipping is unusually common here, too. Flips made up 9.5% of Columbus-area home sales in the second quarter of 2026, one of the highest rates of any large metro,³ so the people who'd make you a private offer are often the same people who'd bid on a listing. You'll still have showings and some waiting, but you skip the repairs and learn what the whole market will pay.

How to put all three choices side by side

A comparison is only fair if every column uses the same date, the same written payoff from your lender and the same facts about the house, and if every net is labeled as an estimate, not a guarantee. List prices should come from real nearby sales you can look up, and the cash column should spell out who pays which closing costs, and I'd hold any agent or buyer to that, including me.

Here's the same made-up house with all three choices, assuming nearby as-is sales support the as-is price shown. The costs are assumptions too, so your numbers will differ.

Same made-up house Fix it, then list List it as-is Private cash offer
Sale price $300,000 $215,000 $165,000
Repairs you pay for $50,000 $0 $0
Selling and closing costs $18,000 $13,000 $2,000
Payments, taxes and utilities while you wait $6,000 $3,000 $1,000
Estimated net before your loan payoff $226,000 $199,000 $162,000

On paper, fixing it up wins by about $27,000, but you'd have to front the repair money, manage contractors for months and absorb any overruns, which is where a lot of fix-up plans lose their edge. Listing as-is leaves about $37,000 more than the private offer here, and that gap is what you'd pay for speed and certainty if you took the cash.

When a cash offer makes sense, and when listing does

A private cash sale tends to come out ahead when the deadline is real, like a closing on your next house or a job that starts in another state next month. It also makes sense when the repairs are more than you can afford or manage, when you live far away, or when you can't keep paying for the house for a few more months, because then a known closing date can be worth more than the extra money a listing might bring.

Listing tends to win when the house only needs paint, cleaning and small repairs, and you have a couple of months. A fair price from day one usually sells close to asking, which on a house in decent shape is far more than an investor's screening math leaves room for.

In September, the typical Central Ohio seller ended up a little under 4% below their first asking price, mostly through cuts after the house had been sitting,⁴ so the price you start at matters more than the price you hope to end at.

When waiting is the smarter move

If the house is vacant, paid off and cheap to carry, there's often no reason to rush. Two real contractor bids tell you what the repairs actually cost, which is the number that decides everything above, and if you still live there, you can sometimes do the small repairs over the winter and list in the spring. If the house is part of an estate, nothing should be signed until the executor has authority to sell and their attorney agrees on the path, which my guide to selling an inherited house in Ohio explains.

What Ohio's wholesaler law requires, and other red flags

Some cash offers come from wholesalers, who sign a contract to buy your house and then sell that contract to another investor for a fee. Since March 2, 2026, Ohio has required a wholesaler to give you a separate written disclosure in bold type, signed and dated by both of you, before you're bound by the contract.⁵ The state's required wording warns that the agreed price "may be below market value," and if you never got that disclosure, the law lets you cancel at any time before closing without penalty and get your earnest money back within 30 days.⁵

A few other things should make you slow down with any cash buyer:

  • The buyer won't put proof of funds in writing or close at a title company you can call yourself.
  • Someone asks for a fee up front, or for the deed before closing.
  • The buyer says selling as-is lets you skip Ohio's disclosure form, which most sellers still have to provide.⁶
  • The price drops after the inspection for problems that were obvious on the first visit.

Plenty of cash buyers are upfront about their math, and these signs just tell you when to slow down. Have an Ohio real estate attorney read any contract you're unsure about before you sign, and if the house was inherited or rented out, ask a CPA how the sale affects your taxes.

Where I come in

When I walk through a house that needs work, I price it as it stands and after the few repairs that tend to pay you back, using the as-is sales near you. You'll get every assumption in writing, including the ones that make listing look worse, so you can check my math the same way this page shows you how to check anyone's.

If you'd like a third column, I can get you an as-is cash number from Wright Home Offer, the company I co-own, on the same worksheet. I buy and renovate houses myself, so I look at your repairs the way a buyer will, and if listing nets you more, I'll tell you to list.

I'm a licensed agent with Red 1 Realty, and I co-own Wright Home Offer. If you sell to Wright Home Offer, I'm on the buyer's side, not your agent, and the company expects to make a profit. You'll get this in writing to sign before we talk numbers, and you're welcome to have your own agent or attorney look at anything.

Questions people ask

How much less do investors pay for houses?

It depends on the repairs, the time involved and the profit the investor needs, so no single percentage is fair to quote. Many investors take 70% of the after-repair value and subtract the repairs, so the more work a house needs, the further an offer falls below its updated value, and you can check any offer against what similar as-is houses near you sold for.

Is a cash offer on a house a scam?

Most aren't, but be careful with anyone who asks for money up front, wants the deed before closing, won't close at a title company you can verify or assigns the contract without Ohio's wholesaler disclosure. An Ohio real estate attorney can review any contract before you sign.

Can I back out of a cash offer after I sign?

That depends on the contract, so have an attorney read the cancellation terms first. If the buyer is a wholesaler who never gave you the disclosure Ohio requires, the law lets you cancel without penalty up until closing and get your earnest money back.

Do I still have to fill out the disclosure form if I sell as-is?

For most Ohio sellers, yes, because selling as-is doesn't remove the state's disclosure form. Some transfers are exempt, like a sale by an estate's executor, and an attorney can tell you whether yours is one.

Walk through it with me

Send the address and a few phone photos of the rough spots, and I'll put the numbers side by side for your house. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or read how to decide what to fix before you sell.

This page is general information, not legal or tax advice. For your contract, talk to an Ohio attorney, and for taxes, a CPA.

Sources

  1. Kiavi, "What Is the 70% Rule in House Flipping?," originally posted Jan 3, 2019, updated July 2026. Formula: maximum allowable offer equals after-repair value times 0.70 minus estimated repairs, described as a screening tool investors adjust. The worked example on this page uses the same round numbers as Kiavi's. https://www.kiavi.com/blog/what-is-the-70-rule-in-house-flipping (seen Oct 25, 2026)
  2. Redfin, "Investor Home Purchases" report for Q1 2026, published May 28, 2026. Investors bought 15% of homes sold in the Columbus metro in Q1 2026, and 19% nationally. https://www.redfin.com/news/investor-report-q1-2026/ (seen Oct 25, 2026)
  3. ATTOM, Q2 2026 U.S. Home Flipping Report, published Oct 1, 2026. Columbus flipping rate 9.5% of home sales, among the highest of metros with more than 1 million people, against 6.2% nationally. https://www.attomdata.com/news/market-trends/flipping/home-flipping-profits-continue-gradual-two-year-decline/ (seen Oct 25, 2026)
  4. Columbus REALTORS, Central Ohio Housing Report, September 2026, published Oct 13, 2026. Sellers received 96.3% of original list price and 98.8% of final list price. https://columbusrealtors.com/news/central-ohio-housing-reports---september-2026
  5. Ohio Revised Code 5301.95, wholesaler disclosure, effective March 2, 2026. Separate, conspicuous, boldface disclosure of at least 12-point type, signed and dated by both parties before a binding contract. Statutory text includes "may be below market value." Without it, the owner may cancel before closing without penalty, and earnest money is returned within thirty days. Assignments to an affiliate under common control are excluded. https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-5301.95 (seen Oct 25, 2026)
  6. Ohio Revised Code 5302.30, residential property disclosure form, effective May 6, 2005. Applies to most residential transfers regardless of other contract terms, with listed exemptions including transfers by a fiduciary administering an estate. https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-5302.30 (seen Oct 25, 2026)

Updated Oct 25, 2026. 7. Disclosure basis: Ohio Revised Code 4735.18(A)(15) and (A)(40), current version effective March 20, 2026, https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-4735.18 , and Ohio Revised Code 4735.71(C), effective Sept 29, 2011, which bars a licensee from acting as a dual agent when the licensee or a company the licensee has an interest in is a party, https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-4735.71 (both seen Oct 25, 2026)

Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty

Aaron Leddy

Red 1 Realty

REALTOR®

(614) 578-5484

Brokered by

Red 1 Realty