Skip to content
Aaron LeddyRed 1 RealtyREALTOR®

Keeping the house in an Ohio divorce, and the buyout math at today's rates

By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated · 9-minute read

The short answer. Keeping the house usually means buying out your spouse's share of the equity and refinancing the whole mortgage into your name alone, at today's rate instead of whatever rate you have now. So before anyone agrees on a buyout number, find out whether you can qualify for that new payment on your own, because that's usually the hardest part of the plan.

I'll send the same value range and the same net sheet to both of you, or to your attorneys or mediator, so everyone's working from one number. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or call (614) 578-5484.

Maybe you and your spouse already agree that one of you should keep the house, and you just need to know whether the numbers work. Maybe the kids are settled at their school and you're trying to figure out whether staying is even possible on one income at today's rates. Either way, there's time to work it out, and it gets a lot easier once you're both looking at the same numbers.

This page walks through a buyout in the order it usually happens and marks the places where your attorneys or mediator make the call. For the bigger picture, including selling instead, start with my guide to selling or keeping the house in an Ohio divorce.

First, agree on one value for the house

Every buyout starts with what the house is worth, and it goes much more smoothly when that number comes from one source that both of you, and both attorneys, can see. When I'm asked for a value in a divorce, both spouses get the same price range, the same list of nearby sales and the same net sheet, in the same message once you're both part of the conversation, or through your attorneys or mediator if you'd rather it go that way. Whoever asks first gets exactly what the other would get, and I won't contact a spouse on my own before the person who called me is ready.

You'll hear about two kinds of value. An appraisal is a licensed appraiser's opinion of value on a certain date, which attorneys may order when the buyout has to hold up in the settlement, and a lender may want its own for the refinance. A market analysis from an agent is a read on what the house would actually sell for this fall, based on nearby sales, condition and competition, and it can come in higher or lower than an appraisal. If you're keeping the house, the appraisal usually drives the buyout, and if you're weighing keeping it against selling it, the market analysis tells you what a sale would really leave you.

Second, work out the equity, both ways

Equity is the agreed value minus everything owed on the house, and Ohio law divides marital property equally unless the court finds that an equal split would be unfair.² Whether the house is all marital property, and what counts as separate, like money one of you put in from before the marriage, is a question for your attorneys.

One judgment call comes up in a lot of buyouts, which is whether to subtract the costs of a sale that isn't going to happen. Some agreements deduct estimated selling costs because the spouse who's leaving would have paid half of them in a sale, and some don't because the house isn't being sold. I'll show it both ways and let the attorneys decide, and here's how that looks on a made-up house.

Made-up example Without selling costs With selling costs
Agreed value $350,000 $350,000
Loan payoff $200,000 $200,000
Estimated selling costs, an assumption $0 $21,000
Equity $150,000 $129,000
Each spouse's half $75,000 $64,500

In this example the choice moves the buyout by $10,500, which is real money for both of you, and it's why the decision belongs in writing in your agreement.

Third, find out whether you can qualify alone

The spouse keeping the house usually needs a new loan big enough to pay off the old mortgage and pay the buyout, and the lender will approve it based on one income, one credit history and today's rate. In the example above, that new loan would have to cover the $200,000 payoff and the $75,000 buyout, so you'd be qualifying alone for about $275,000 before closing costs, with taxes and insurance on top of the payment.

So ask a lender for a pre-approval on the refinance before you sign anything, using the buyout number from your draft agreement. If the payment doesn't work, it's far better to find out now, while there's still room to trade the house against other assets or set a later sale date.

Can you keep the old loan instead of refinancing?

Sometimes, and it's worth asking, because keeping a low rate can change the whole picture. Federal law stops a lender from calling the loan due just because a divorce decree or property settlement puts the house in one spouse's name.⁴ That protects the transfer, but the departing spouse is still on the mortgage and still liable for it until the lender agrees to release them, and whether a lender will do that depends on the loan.

  • On a Fannie Mae loan, a transfer to a spouse under a divorce decree is allowed as long as that spouse lives in the house, and if the departing spouse asks to be released, the servicer has to find the remaining spouse's credit and finances acceptable first.⁵
  • FHA loans are assumable, and for loans closed since late 1989, the person taking over the loan has to pass a credit review, after which HUD's rules call for the original borrower to be released.⁶
  • VA loans can be assumed by someone who meets VA's credit standards, and if the spouse who isn't the veteran keeps the house, an assumption may be needed to release the veteran, whose entitlement generally stays tied to that loan unless an eligible veteran substitutes their own.⁷

Ask your servicer, in writing, which of these applies to your loan before your agreement counts on one of them. Your attorney will likely want the release, or a deadline to refinance, written into the decree, because staying liable on a loan you no longer control is a real risk for the spouse who moves out.

In Franklin County, the house is frozen once the case is filed

When either spouse files a complaint for divorce, legal separation or annulment in Franklin County, a standard restraining order takes effect that same day and bars both of you from selling or borrowing against the house, along with other assets.⁸ It stays in place until the court changes it or the final judgment is filed, so a sale or a refinance during the case usually takes an agreed court order, and your attorneys will know how to ask for one. If your case is in Madison or Union County, ask your attorney whether a similar order applies there.

When waiting is the smarter move

Sometimes the best buyout is a later one, or none at all. If you can both afford it and the kids are partway through a school year, some couples write a deferred sale into the decree, with the house sold by a set date or event and the agreement spelling out who pays the mortgage, taxes and repairs until then. Your attorneys can tell you whether that fits your case and how to protect both of you while you still share the house on paper.

If the refinance doesn't work at today's rate, a deferred sale is usually better than a loan that leaves the keeper stretched every month. And if one of you isn't ready to decide, pushing a buyout or a listing through anyway tends to go badly for everyone, so it's worth waiting for an agreement or a court order before anybody signs.

Taxes when the house moves between spouses

The IRS generally treats a transfer of your home, or your share of it, to a spouse or former spouse as part of a divorce settlement as having no gain or loss.⁹ Later, when the spouse who kept it sells, a single filer can usually exclude up to $250,000 of gain, and the IRS has special rules that can count a spouse's or former spouse's ownership and use toward the tests for that exclusion.⁹ How those rules work for you, including whether selling before or after the decree changes your exclusion, is a question for a CPA, and it's worth asking before the agreement is final.

Where I come in, and where I stop

My part is the value and the net sheet, plus the listing if you decide to sell instead. Once you're both involved, anything important I send goes to both of you. I won't share one spouse's new address or schedule with the other, and if there's any concern about contact, I'm glad to work only through your attorneys. Who gets the house, what counts as separate property and how the rest of your assets balance out are questions for your attorneys or mediator, and the tax side belongs to a CPA.

Questions people ask

How do I buy out my spouse's share of the house?

Agree on a value, subtract what's owed to find the equity, and pay your spouse their share, usually through a cash-out refinance in your name or by trading other assets. Your attorneys decide how the equity is split, and a lender decides whether you can carry the new loan alone.

Can a spouse assume the mortgage in a divorce?

Often the spouse keeping the house can stay on the existing loan, because federal law keeps the lender from calling it due over a transfer in a divorce decree. Getting the other spouse released from the debt is a separate step that needs the lender's approval, and FHA and VA loans have their own assumption rules.

Do we need an appraisal for a divorce buyout?

Many couples use one, especially when the buyout has to hold up in the settlement. A market analysis from an agent is a good first look at whether keeping the house or selling it leaves more, and I don't charge for one.

Can I sell or refinance the house while the divorce is pending?

In Franklin County, filing a divorce complaint puts a restraining order in place that bars both spouses from selling or borrowing against the house until the court changes it or the case ends. Your attorneys can ask the court for an agreed order if you both want to sell or refinance.

What if I can't qualify for the refinance on my own?

Then the buyout probably needs a different shape, like trading the house against other assets, setting a deferred sale date or selling and splitting the proceeds. Getting a lender pre-approval early tells you which of those to talk through with your attorney.

Start from one number you both trust

I'll send the same value range and the same net sheet to both of you, or to your attorneys or mediator, so everyone's working from one number. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or call (614) 578-5484.

This page is general information, not legal or tax advice. Your attorneys or mediator decide how property is divided, and a CPA should review the tax side.

Sources

  1. Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, 30-year fixed average 7.24% for the week of Oct 29, 2026, up from 6.17% a year earlier. https://www.freddiemac.com/pmms
  2. Ohio Revised Code 3105.171, effective Sept 30, 2025. Marital property is divided equally unless an equal division would be inequitable, property acquired by one spouse before the marriage is separate property, and the court may order the sale or encumbrance of property. https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-3105.171 (seen Oct 25, 2026)
  3. Arithmetic on a 30-year fixed loan. Principal and interest per $100,000 is about $422 at 3.00% and about $681 at 7.24%, a difference of about $260. The example's new loan is about $275,000, the $200,000 payoff plus the $75,000 buyout before closing costs. Illustration only, not a loan offer. Rate from source 1.
  4. 12 U.S.C. 1701j-3(d)(7), Garn-St Germain Act. A lender may not exercise a due-on-sale clause on a transfer resulting from a decree of dissolution of marriage, a legal separation agreement or an incidental property settlement agreement by which the borrower's spouse becomes an owner, on residential property of fewer than five units. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/12/1701j-3 (seen Oct 25, 2026)
  5. Fannie Mae Servicing Guide D1-4.1-02, Allowable Exemptions Due to the Type of Transfer, dated Aug 13, 2025. Exempt transfer to a spouse under a divorce decree or legal separation agreement as long as the transferee will occupy the property, and the servicer must find the transferee's credit and financial capacity acceptable before releasing the previous borrower. https://servicing-guide.fanniemae.com/svc/d1-4.1-02/allowable-exemptions-due-type-transfer (seen Oct 25, 2026)
  6. HUD Handbook 4155.1, Chapter 7, Assumptions. All FHA-insured mortgages are assumable, mortgages closed on or after Dec 15, 1989 require credit qualification of the person assuming, and the lender prepares a release of liability for the original borrower when a creditworthy person assumes the debt. https://www.hud.gov/sites/documents/4155-1_7.pdf (seen Oct 25, 2026)
  7. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, Loan Guaranty Service, "Assumptions" presentation, 2023 lender conference. For loans committed on or after March 1, 1988, an assumption requires VA credit standards and releases liability, the original veteran's entitlement stays tied to the property unless an eligible veteran substitutes entitlement, and when a non-veteran spouse is awarded the property, an assumption may be needed to release the veteran. https://www.benefits.va.gov/HOMELOANS/documents/conf/2023-lender-d3-01-assumptions.pdf (seen Oct 25, 2026)
  8. Franklin County Court of Common Pleas, Division of Domestic Relations, Local Rule 43, effective Jan 30, 2017, https://drj.fccourts.org/Administration/Local-Rules/Domestic-Court-Rules/43-Standard-Mutual-Temporary-Restraining-Orders , and Standard Mutual Temporary Restraining Order form eDR3006, https://drj.fccourts.org/files/assets/courtofpleas/v/1/administration/documents/local-rules/standard-mutual-temporary-restraining-order_edr3006-1-2017_v3.pdf (both seen Oct 25, 2026). Effective on filing, each spouse is enjoined from "selling ... encumbering, disposing of" assets including real property, until a court order modifies it or a judgment is filed.
  9. IRS Publication 523 (2025), Selling Your Home. A transfer of a home or a share of it to a spouse or ex-spouse as part of a divorce settlement is generally treated as no gain or loss, the exclusion is up to $250,000, or $500,000 for married couples filing jointly, and special rules cover a spouse's ownership time and a former spouse's use under a divorce or separation instrument. https://www.irs.gov/publications/p523 (seen Oct 25, 2026)

Updated Oct 25, 2026.

Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty

Aaron Leddy

Red 1 Realty

REALTOR®

(614) 578-5484

Brokered by

Red 1 Realty