Skip to content
Aaron LeddyRed 1 RealtyREALTOR®

New construction in Plain City, and the schools and taxes that come with it

By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated

If you're looking at a new build with a Plain City address, the mailing name won't tell you much, because a 43064 address can sit in Madison or Union County, in Jonathan Alder Local Schools, Dublin City Schools or Fairbanks Local Schools, and inside or outside the village, each with different taxes. The parcel answers most of it, and nothing has to be decided at the model. I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty, and I'll check the parcel for any lot you're considering before you sign.

Send me the community before you walk into the model, because some builders only let your own agent help if they're with you on that first visit. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or call (614) 578-5484.

Which school district a community is in

I put each builder's own map point or sales office through the Census Bureau's geocoder, and here's where each one lands, next to what the builder says.
Plain City new-construction communities: where the map puts themOne map point per community, the builder's own pin or sales office, and your lot can differ, so check the parcel.
CommunityCounty and townshipInside the village?School district on the mapLocal income taxesWhat the builder saysPrice, as advertised
Darby StationM/I HomesMadison County, Darby TownshipYesJonathan Alder Local SchoolsVillage 1.5%, school district 1.25%"Jonathan Alder Local School District will serve Darby Station students" (builder's page, opens in a new tab)Priced from $451,900Seen Oct 25, 2026
Madison Meadows PatiosD.R. HortonMadison County, Darby TownshipYesJonathan Alder Local SchoolsVillage 1.5%, school district 1.25%Names Jonathan Alder Local Schools (builder's page, opens in a new tab)From $393,990 ("Final Opportunities")Seen Oct 25, 2026
Del Webb Maygrass (55+)Del WebbUnion County, Jerome TownshipNoJonathan Alder Local SchoolsNo village tax, school district 1.25%Not stated on the page I checkedStarting at the Low $400'sSeen Oct 25, 2026
Jerome Village (welcome center)12 buildersUnion County, Jerome TownshipNoDublin City SchoolsNo village tax, no school district income tax"located primarily in the Dublin City School District" (builder's page, opens in a new tab)Varies by builder and neighborhoodSeen Oct 25, 2026
Meadowlark at Jerome VillageFischer HomesUnion County, Jerome TownshipNoFairbanks Local SchoolsNo village tax, school district 1%Lists Fairbanks Local School District schools (builder's page, opens in a new tab)New Homes Starting at $476,990Seen Oct 25, 2026

Map check Oct 25, 2026 · U.S. Census Bureau Geocoder, current boundaries

Meadowlark at Jerome Village is the clearest example. The name says Jerome Village, and Jerome Village says it's primarily in Dublin City Schools, but at Fischer's map point for Meadowlark the Census map shows Fairbanks Local Schools, and Fischer lists Fairbanks schools on its own page. Del Webb Maygrass, in the same township, maps to Jonathan Alder Local Schools.

I know how easy that line is to miss, because my family lives inside the Village of Plain City, in the Jonathan Alder district, about 18 minutes from Jerome Village and its Plain City mailing addresses.

Whether Plain City has an income tax

Inside the village, yes. The Village of Plain City taxes residents' income at 1.5%, and its income tax page says “No credit is given for taxes paid to other cities or villages.” So if the city where you work withholds its own tax, you pay the village tax as well.

Much of the new building with a Plain City address, including the Jerome Village area, sits in unincorporated Jerome Township, outside the village, and a home there doesn't pay the village income tax even with a Plain City mailing address.

The school district then adds its own income tax wherever you live in it. Jonathan Alder Local Schools adds 1.25% on earned income only, Fairbanks Local Schools adds 1% on most income, and Dublin City Schools adds none.

A tax preparer can tell you what these mean for your own income.

Sources

Village of Plain City, Income Tax FAQ, checked Oct 25, 2026. Ohio Department of Taxation, School Districts With an Income Tax for 2026 (effective Jan 1, 2026), checked Oct 25, 2026.

How to check any lot before you sign

  1. Find the county, since the Plain City communities I mapped fall in Madison County or Union County.

  2. Open that county auditor's parcel record for the lot.

  3. Read the school district and tax district on the parcel record instead of the mailing address.

  4. Check whether the parcel is inside the Village of Plain City, which decides the 1.5% village income tax.

  5. For a lot near a line, call the school district and ask.

  6. Look up the current property tax rate for that tax district on the auditor's site.

What the Plain City market means for you

If you're selling a resale house in Plain City right now, your real competition is the builders down the road and whatever incentives they're advertising that month, so your price and condition have to hold up next to a brand-new house. If you're buying, that same competition works for you, because sellers here have more reason to negotiate than they did a year ago.

Homes in the Jonathan Alder schools took about 46 days to sell in September, up from 36 a year earlier, so you'll usually have time to compare a new build with a resale before you decide.

Sources

Columbus REALTORS Local Market Update, Jonathan Alder Local School District, September 2026, published Oct 13, 2026.

Questions about building in Plain City

What school district is Plain City new construction in?
It depends on the community and the lot. At the builders' own map points on the Census Bureau's map, Darby Station, Madison Meadows Patios and Del Webb Maygrass land in Jonathan Alder Local Schools, the Jerome Village welcome center lands in Dublin City Schools, and Meadowlark at Jerome Village lands in Fairbanks Local Schools, so check the parcel for your lot.
Is Jerome Village in Dublin schools?
Mostly. Jerome Village says it's "located primarily in the Dublin City School District," and its welcome center maps to Dublin City Schools, but Meadowlark at Jerome Village maps to Fairbanks Local Schools and Fischer lists Fairbanks schools on its own page for it. Check the parcel for the lot you're looking at.
Does Plain City have an income tax?
Inside the village, yes. The village charges 1.5% and says "No credit is given for taxes paid to other cities or villages." Homes outside the village limits, like those in Jerome Township, don't pay the village tax, and the school districts add their own, with Jonathan Alder Local Schools at 1.25% on earned income only, Fairbanks Local Schools at 1% and Dublin City Schools at none.
Which builders are building in Plain City?
On the community pages seen Oct 25, 2026, the builders were 3 Pillar Homes, Arbor Homes, Bob Webb Homes, Coastal Ridge, D.R. Horton, Del Webb, Epcon Communities, Fischer Homes, M/I Homes, Manor Homes, Memmer Homes, Rockford Homes, Romanelli & Hughes, Schottenstein Homes and Virginia Homes. That isn't every builder with a lot in the 43064 ZIP.
Is Plain City part of Columbus?
No. The Village of Plain City is its own municipality with its own income tax, and much of the new building with a Plain City mailing address sits outside the village, in Jerome Township in Union County.

If you're thinking about living here more than building here, there's more on Plain City as a place to live, and the 55+ community has its own page on Del Webb Maygrass.

Before you walk into a Plain City model

Send me the community before you walk into the model, because some builders only let your own agent help if they're with you on that first visit. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or call (614) 578-5484.

Rather write it out?

A neighborhood, a builder or a town is plenty.

Step 1 of 2

I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Sources

Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty

Aaron Leddy

Red 1 Realty

REALTOR®

(614) 578-5484

Brokered by

Red 1 Realty