Renting or buying in Central Ohio, with every cost counted
By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated · 8-minute read
The short answer
Month to month, renting is often cheaper around Central Ohio right now. Over several years, buying tends to win if you'll stay about five years or more, because the core payment stays flat and part of each payment pays down your loan.
Send me your rent and the areas you'd consider, and I'll put a real payment on real houses there next to what you pay now. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
Maybe your rent just went up at renewal, and you're wondering whether a mortgage would really cost that much more. Maybe everyone in your family has an opinion about which one is smarter. You don't have to pick a side this week, and renting really is the better choice for some people.
Here's the math the way I'd walk through it with you, with the costs on both sides counted. I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty, and I'd rather tell you to keep renting than help you buy a house that strains you.
What owning really costs each month
Real buying math adds the principal, the interest, the property taxes and the insurance, and the taxes and insurance change a lot by county, school district and the house itself.
Then there's upkeep, because furnaces fail and water heaters quit at bad times, so the right habit is setting aside something every month. If there's an HOA, count that too, since the only version of this math worth trusting is the one that counts everything.
What renting really costs
Rent has costs too, and they're just quieter. Typical Columbus-area rent was up a little under 3% from a year earlier, which is the kind of increase a fixed-rate mortgage payment never hands you.
Renters also tend to move more often, which means deposits, overlap months and days off work, and every dollar of rent buys a place to live without building anything behind you.
Where a mortgage payment goes in the first five years
In the early years, most of each payment goes to interest, which disappoints people to hear, but the split shifts a little toward principal every month. That principal is equity you own, and it builds even if home values never move, which makes it work like savings inside a payment you were making anyway.
Prices around Central Ohio have kept rising slowly, with the typical sale up a little under 3% from a year ago, but the loan paydown doesn't depend on that, and it works in a flat market too.
How long you'd need to stay
The cleanest rule of thumb I can give you is five years. If you're confident you'll stay at least that long, buying usually has time to work, and if you'll likely leave within two or three, renting usually wins, because the costs of buying and selling come out of your equity while the early paydown is still small.
Given time, the lines cross, since rent keeps stepping up while your principal and interest stay flat, so the most important question here is how long you'll actually stay.
Who should keep renting for now
Some people should keep renting, and in these cases renting buys flexibility, which is worth paying for when your life needs it:
- You expect to move within two or three years
- Buying would drain your savings, with nothing left for repairs
- Your income is uncertain right now
- The payment only fits if you stretch
- You rent cheaply and invest the difference with real discipline
What I'd do
I'd put your current rent next to a real payment on real houses in the areas you'd actually live, with taxes and insurance included, and look at where the two lines cross for your timeline. If renting is your better move for now, that's what you'd hear from me, along with what would need to change for buying to make sense.
Put your rent next to a real payment
Send me your rent and the areas you'd consider, and I'll put a real payment on real houses there next to what you pay now. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
Sources
- Columbus REALTORS Central Ohio Housing Report, September 2026, published Oct 13, 2026: median sale price $334,250, up 2.8% from a year earlier, sellers received 96.3% of original and 98.8% of final list price, 6,530 homes for sale, up 12.3%, 33 days on market against 30 a year earlier, 2.6 months of supply, pending sales down 12.7%. Area figures come from the same release's per-area reports. columbusrealtors.com (opens in a new tab), checked Oct 25, 2026.
- Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI), Columbus, OH metro, all home types, smoothed, $1,525 in September 2026 against $1,482 a year earlier. zillow.com (opens in a new tab), checked Oct 25, 2026.
Updated .
