New construction or resale in Central Ohio, and how to decide
By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated · 6-minute read
The short answer
The fairest way to compare them is by the monthly cost, with everything added in. A resale usually comes finished and can close in about a month, while a new build can take months, may carry an HOA and comes with a builder financing offer that can change the math. The model-home salesperson works for the builder, so it helps to bring your own agent.
Send me the community you're looking at and a resale you like, and I'll compare them as a monthly cost, builder fine print included. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
Maybe you toured a model home and a resale on the same weekend and came home torn between them. Maybe the new build has the layout you want, but the older house is closer in and ready now. You don't have to pick a side today, and the choice gets a lot easier once both houses are in the same terms.
Here's how I'd compare them so the decision fits your timeline and your monthly budget. I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty, and I help buyers on both sides of this choice.
What the price includes
A model home is dressed to sell, so the base price rarely matches what you walked through once upgrades, lot premiums and finishes are added. A resale often comes with landscaping, blinds and a fence already in place, which are real costs a new build may not include in the first year, so add them in before you compare.
Timing
A resale can usually close in about a month, while a new build can take several months or more depending on where construction stands when you sign. If you have a lease ending or a house to sell, that gap shapes the whole plan, so ask the builder for the current timeline in writing before you count on a date.
The monthly cost
The number that matters is the payment, the taxes and any HOA, added together, and property taxes alone can change a lot from one school district to the next.
A new build can cost less to keep up in the early years, and a resale may cost less each month at the same price, so run both as one monthly number.
Reading a builder's offer
When a builder offers a credit or a lower rate, check whether it requires the builder's lender, which homes it covers and the closing deadline, and whether the price gives some of it back. A buydown that lowers the rate for the first year or two works differently from a lower rate for the life of the loan, so ask for the year-three payment and the APR.
Upgrades that get rolled into the price are paid for over thirty years, so look at what they add to the loan before you say yes to them.
Who's on your side
The salesperson in the model home is good at the job, and the job is the builder's interest. You can bring your own agent, and whether the builder covers that fee depends on the builder, so get it confirmed in writing before you sign anything.
Some builders only let your agent help if they come along on your first visit, so check each builder's rule before you walk into a model. Here's what to do before your first model visit.
What I'd do
I'd match the choice to your timeline, your monthly budget and how much you want to customize, then run both houses as a monthly number side by side. If a resale is the better math for you, that's what I'd tell you, even when the new build is the more exciting tour.
Put both houses in the same terms
Send me the community you're looking at and a resale you like, and I'll compare them as a monthly cost, builder fine print included. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
Sources
Updated .
