Skip to content
Aaron LeddyRed 1 RealtyREALTOR®

Relist now or wait for spring?

The math for a Columbus house that didn't sell

By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated · 8-minute read

The short answer. Wait if you can carry the house comfortably, you still live there, and the main problem was timing. Relist now, after fixing whatever held it back, if the house is empty and costing you money every month or it sits in an area where similar homes are still going under contract quickly. Either way, find out why it didn't sell before you decide when to try again.

Send the address. I'll show you what sold nearby while yours was listed and what I'd change, and if the honest answer is to wait until spring, I'll tell you that. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or call (614) 578-5484.

If your listing just expired and the sign is still in the yard, you're probably tired of keeping the house ready for strangers and not sure whether to try again now or let it rest. Maybe you've already moved and you're paying for two places, or maybe you still live there and the showings have worn everyone out. Nothing about this has to be decided today, and for some people waiting really is the smarter move.

This guide runs the numbers both ways, using what actually happened in Central Ohio this year, so you can see what spring might add and what waiting would cost you. It's part of my guide to what to do when your house didn't sell. I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty, and if your house is still listed with another agent, that agent is the right person to talk this through with first.

What happened this fall

More homes are sitting this fall, so if yours didn't sell, you've got a lot of company. In September, Central Ohio sellers got about 96% of their original asking price but about 99% of their final asking price,¹ which means most of the discount came from price cuts after a house had been on the market for a while. With more homes for sale than a year ago, buyers had more to compare, so the starting price mattered more than it has in years.¹

Figure out why it didn't sell first

Before you choose between now and spring, it helps to know what actually held the house back, because waiting won't fix a price or presentation problem. Your old listing's showing count and the feedback from buyers' agents usually tell the story.

  • Lots of showings and no offers usually points to the price, or to a condition problem buyers noticed in person.
  • Few showings usually points to the price or to the photos and online listing, since buyers decided before they ever came out.
  • Offers that fell apart point to an inspection or appraisal problem that's worth fixing or disclosing up front next time.
  • Steady interest that faded as the weather turned may really have been timing.

If it was timing, spring can help. If it was the price or the presentation, those problems follow the house into spring, where you'll be up against more listings.

What spring is worth, in dollars

Columbus homes listed in the first two weeks of May 2025 sold for about 3% more, roughly $10,500 on a typical home.² That's real money, but it's an average from last year rather than a promise for 2027, and it goes to houses that are priced and presented well on the day they hit the market.

What waiting costs, worked out

Here's how the cost of waiting works on a typical house over the six months from mid-November to early May. Every figure below is an estimate for illustration, so swap in your own bills before you decide anything.

Monthly cost of holding the house Estimate
Property taxes, estimated at $6,000 a year $500
Homeowners insurance, estimated at $1,800 a year $150
Utilities through the winter, estimated $300
Mortgage interest, estimated on $200,000 still owed at a 4% rate $667
Total per month, estimated about $1,617
Six months, estimated about $9,700

Only the interest part of your mortgage payment belongs in this math, because the principal you pay down each month comes back to you as equity when the house sells. On these estimates, six months of waiting costs about as much as the whole spring premium if the house sits empty, before you've sold anything.

If you still live there, most of those costs are what you'd pay to live anywhere, so the true cost of waiting is much smaller. What you're really taking on is the risk that rates or the market move against you between now and May, which nobody can predict, including me.

What winter selling is really like

A lot of sellers assume winter is dead, but buyers keep shopping. In January 2026, Central Ohio homes took a median of about 48 days to sell, and more homes went under contract than the January before,³ so the buyers were out there, just in less of a hurry and choosing among fewer houses.

That flips in spring. Central Ohio had about 25% more homes for sale in May 2026 than in January,³ ⁴ so a house that waits for spring meets more buyers and a lot more competition, and it only comes out ahead if it's priced right when it gets there.

What to fix over the winter

If you decide to wait, use the time on whatever held the house back. That might mean a pre-listing inspection so there are no surprises in April, the repairs buyers kept mentioning, decluttering and fresh paint while it's quiet, and new photos lined up for the day it relists. It also means watching what sells near you over the winter, because those sales will set the right price in May.

Who should wait, and who shouldn't

If this sounds like you What usually makes sense
You still live there, can carry it comfortably, and interest faded with the weather Wait, fix what you can, and relist in spring
The house is empty and you're paying for two places Relist now with a corrected price and fresh photos
You have a move date or another deadline before spring Relist now, priced where similar homes are going under contract
You had plenty of showings and no offers Fix the price or the condition first, because waiting won't change it
You're no longer sure you want to sell Take it off, live in it, and decide in the new year, or look at renting it

If the house will sit empty over the winter, call your insurance agent before you decide to wait, since some policies treat a vacant house differently, and a frozen pipe can cost more than spring would ever add.

Where I come in, and where I stop

If your listing has expired or been canceled, I'll pull what sold, went under contract or took a price cut near you while yours was listed, and tell you which of those reasons it most likely was. If the house is still listed, or it was withdrawn but your agreement hasn't run out yet, please talk with your current agent first, because Ohio license law and the REALTOR® Code of Ethics don't let me work around another agent's exclusive listing.⁵ Every Ohio listing agreement has to include an expiration date, so that's the place to check if you're not sure where you stand.⁶

If you're done waiting altogether

If the house needs more work than you want to take on, or you've simply run out of patience, there's a second option. I co-own Wright Home Offer, a company that buys houses as-is. Once your old listing has fully ended, and before you sign a new listing with anyone, I can get you its cash number and put it next to what I think the house would net on the open market, side by side. If listing nets you more, I'll tell you to list.

I'm a licensed agent with Red 1 Realty, and I co-own Wright Home Offer. If you sell to Wright Home Offer, I'm on the buyer's side, not your agent, and the company expects to make a profit. You'll get this in writing to sign before we talk numbers, and you're welcome to have your own agent or attorney look at anything.

Questions people ask

Should I take my house off the market in winter?

Not necessarily. If the house is priced right and you're comfortable with fewer, more serious buyers, staying on through the winter can work, especially where similar homes are still going under contract. If showings have dried up and you're worn out, taking a break, fixing what held it back and relisting in spring is a reasonable plan.

Why is my house not selling?

Most of the time it comes down to price, condition or how the listing looks online, and sometimes it's the season. Your showing count and buyer feedback usually point to which one, and the homes that sold near you while yours was listed will tell you whether the price was the problem.

My home didn't sell. Now what?

Start by finding out why, then decide between relisting now, waiting for spring or taking a break altogether. Check your old listing agreement's expiration date before you talk with other agents, and if you're unsure what the agreement says, an attorney can review it for you.

Is it a mistake to relist right away?

Not if something meaningful changes, like the price, the photos or a repair buyers kept mentioning. Putting the same house back on at the same price usually gets the same result, so the change matters more than the timing.

Take a fresh look before you relist

Send the address. I'll show you what sold nearby while yours was listed and what I'd change, and if the honest answer is to wait until spring, I'll tell you that. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.

Or call (614) 578-5484.

The cost figures on this page are illustrations, not quotes or predictions, and nobody can promise what spring will bring. If your old listing agreement is in dispute, talk with an attorney.

Sources

  1. Columbus REALTORS, Central Ohio Housing Report, September 2026, published Oct 13, 2026 (sellers received 96.3% of original list price and 98.8% of final list price, inventory 6,530, up 12.3%, pending sales down 12.7%, and 2026 president Gloria Alonso Cannon: "With more competition on the market, the starting price matters more than ever"). https://columbusrealtors.com/news/central-ohio-housing-reports---september-2026 (seen 2026-10-25)
  2. Zillow, "Best time to list: Homes sell for $6,000 more in late May," March 18, 2026 (Columbus: first two weeks of May, 3.1% premium, about $10,500; based on 2025 sales in the 35 largest metros). https://zillow.mediaroom.com/2026-03-18-Best-time-to-list-Homes-sell-for-6,000-more-in-late-May (seen 2026-10-25)
  3. Columbus REALTORS, Central Ohio Housing Report, January 2026, published Feb 12, 2026 (median days on market 48; inventory 4,164; pending sales 2,152, up 5.5% year over year; 1.7 months of supply). https://columbusrealtors.com/news/central-ohio-housing-report---january-2026 (seen 2026-10-25)
  4. Columbus REALTORS, Central Ohio Housing Report, May 2026, published June 10, 2026 (inventory 5,223, which is about 25% above January's 4,164). https://columbusrealtors.com/news/central-ohio-housing-report---may-2026 (seen 2026-10-25)
  5. Ohio Revised Code 4735.18(A)(19), effective March 20, 2026 (negotiating directly with a seller known to be under an exclusive listing with another broker). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-4735.18 (seen 2026-10-25)
  6. Ohio Revised Code 4735.55, effective Sept 30, 2025 (written agency agreements must include "An expiration date"). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-4735.55 (seen 2026-10-25)

Carrying-cost table: every input (taxes of $6,000 a year, insurance of $1,800 a year, utilities of $300 a month, $200,000 owed at 4%) is an illustrative estimate chosen for a house worth roughly $340,000, not a sourced average. Interest is $200,000 x 4% / 12, about $667 a month. This is an illustration, not a loan offer. Your rate, APR and payment depend on your lender, credit and costs. Updated Oct 25, 2026.

Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty

Aaron Leddy

Red 1 Realty

REALTOR®

(614) 578-5484

Brokered by

Red 1 Realty