Ready for less house? How to downsize around Columbus
By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated
Maybe the kids are grown, the stairs are getting old, and the house you raised everyone in is starting to feel like more than you need. There's no rush, and there's no wrong reason to stay or go.
I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty, and I'll help you see what your house could net, what the next place would really cost each month, and whether now is the right time at all.
Send me your address and what you're looking for next, and I'll show you what your house could net and what the next place would cost each month. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
Or call (614) 578-5484.
Start from where you are
Pick the line that sounds most like you.
I'm starting to wonder whether this house is more than I need.
Wondering is a fine place to be for a while, and for some people a few changes, like moving a bedroom downstairs or getting help with the yard, make staying the better choice for years.
I'm weighing what a smaller place would really cost.
A smaller place isn't always a cheaper one, so the useful comparison is what the next home would cost each month with taxes, insurance and any association fees, next to what you'd have left after selling this one.
I'm ready to make the move and want to do it once.
The move that's easiest on you usually starts with picking the next place first and then selling with enough time built in to move once, and your family is welcome at every conversation along the way.
What the next place really costs each month
Start with the full monthly cost of the place you're considering, not just its price. That means the property tax bill on its value, the homeowners or condo insurance, the utilities and any association dues, along with what those dues actually cover, since some include the lawn, the snow and even the roof and others cover a lot less.
Then work out what you'd have left after selling this house, which is the price minus the loan payoff and the costs of selling. You can run your own net sheet in a few minutes. A new one-story home with association dues can cost more each month than a paid-off two-story, and a smaller resale can cost a lot less, so it helps to see both numbers on the same page before you fall for a floor plan.
Selling one house and buying the next without moving twice
The timeline for the next place usually sets the timeline for this one. A resale or a finished new home can close in a matter of weeks, while a home that hasn't been built yet can take many months, and you'll want to know which one you're waiting on before you list.
When you sell, a buyer can agree to a later closing or to let you stay a short time after closing, and either one can save you a second move and a storage unit. If you'd rather move first and sell the house empty, call your insurance agent about vacancy coverage the week you leave. The page on selling one house and buying the next walks through every way to put the two in order.
Your choices, and what each one costs
Listing it as it is. A house that's been loved for a long time often has an original kitchen or baths, and buyers expect that and price for it. A price that reflects the condition from the first day usually serves you better than one that has to be cut later.
Listing it after light prep. Paint, flooring, lighting and a tidy yard are usually the short list, and the point is to do only the work buyers will pay you back for.
Buying a new one-story home. Builders around Columbus are putting up ranch plans and homes with the main bedroom on the first floor, some in communities with their own association rules. The salesperson in the model home works for the builder, so it's worth having your own agent with you from the first visit, and the page on building a new house around Columbus covers what to do before you walk in. If you're looking near Plain City, the page on Del Webb Maygrass lays out that community's rules, features and what to ask first.
Renting instead of buying. Selling and renting can make sense if you'd like the equity in hand or you aren't sure yet where you'll land. Keep in mind that rent can change at every renewal, while the biggest costs of a paid-off house are taxes, insurance and upkeep, so run both for several years out, not just the first one.
How much of the gain stays out of federal tax
A married couple can generally leave up to $500,000 of gain on a main home out of federal tax, or $250,000 for a single owner, at any age, and a surviving spouse can still use the larger figure if the house sells within two years. Most Central Ohio downsizers owe no federal tax on the sale, but long-time owners and anyone recently widowed should check the numbers with a CPA before picking a closing date.
When waiting is the smarter move
If the house is paid off, the stairs are manageable and the move would mean a new mortgage at today's rates plus association dues, staying put a few more years can be the better answer for your money, and I'll tell you so.
Waiting has a cost too, mostly the upkeep and the empty rooms you heat and cool, so it helps to see both numbers even if you don't act on them yet. A lot of people find the decision gets easier once it's on paper, whichever way it goes.
Taxes and timing, worth a CPA's look
To use the home sale exclusion, you generally need to have owned the house and lived in it as your main home for two of the last five years, and gain above the exclusion is taxed as a capital gain. A large gain can also raise Medicare premiums later, because Medicare's income-based charge uses the tax return from a couple of years back, so the year you sell can matter as much as the price.
Your property tax credits at the new address
Ohio's property tax credits don't follow you to a new address, so when you move, you apply again through the auditor in the county where the new home sits. That includes the owner-occupancy credit for living in your own home, which a recent state law is growing over the next few years, and the homestead exemption if you qualify for it. If you had the homestead exemption for 2013, the state says you won't have to report your income again when you apply at the new home, though you still have to apply. The page on property taxes that went up covers both credits in more detail.
Listing it, or an as-is number to compare
If the house is dated and you'd rather not prep it or keep it ready for showings, there's a second option. I co-own Wright Home Offer, a company that buys houses as-is, and I can get you its cash number and put it next to what I think the house would net on the open market, side by side and in writing.
Bring a family member or anyone you trust into that conversation, take as long as you like and get another opinion if you want one. If listing nets you more, I'll tell you to list.
I'm a licensed agent with Red 1 Realty, and I co-own Wright Home Offer. If you sell to Wright Home Offer, I'm on the buyer's side, not your agent, and the company expects to make a profit. You'll get this in writing to sign before we talk numbers, and you're welcome to have your own agent or attorney look at anything.
How I'd help, and where I stop
I'll run both sides of the move with you, what your house could net after the payoff and the costs of selling, and what the next place would cost each month with everything counted. If you'd like your family or anyone else you trust on the call or at the kitchen table, they're welcome at every step.
When it's time to buy the next place, I can be your agent on that side too, so the two closings line up and you move once.
I'm a REALTOR®, not a tax adviser or a financial planner, so a CPA should look at the tax side, and questions about the homestead exemption or the owner-occupancy credit belong with your county auditor.
Here's how this usually goes
A common pattern, not one specific client.
Usually it's someone who's been in the same house for twenty or thirty years, and the stairs, the yard or the empty rooms have started to feel like more than they want to keep up with. The sale is often the easy part, and the harder part is deciding what's next and what to do with everything inside. We put the full monthly cost of the next place, with taxes, dues and insurance, next to what your house costs now, and decide together how much of the sale goes into the next home. If the gain is large, a CPA should look at it before you pick a closing date. There's no deadline, so if the answer is next spring, that's fine.
Questions people ask
Should I buy the next place first or sell my house first?
Will I owe tax when I sell a house I've owned for years?
Does the old over-55 home sale exclusion still apply?
Does my Ohio homestead exemption move with me?
Do I have to fix up the house before I sell it?
Run the numbers before you decide
Send me your address and what you're looking for next, and I'll show you what your house could net and what the next place would cost each month. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
Or call (614) 578-5484.
Rather write it out?
Guides for this situation
Sources
- IRS Publication 523 (2025), Selling Your Home (exclude up to $250,000 of gain, $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly, a surviving spouse who sells within 2 years of the spouse's death and hasn't remarried may use $500,000, owned and used as a residence for at least 24 months of the 5 years before the sale), irs.gov/publications/p523, seen 2026-11-05.
- IRS Publication 553 (1997): “This new exclusion generally replaces the old ‘rollover’ rules and the one-time $125,000 exclusion for taxpayers age 55 and older. Those rules generally apply to sales before May 7, 1997,” irs.gov, seen 2026-11-05.
- Medicare.gov, 2026 Medicare costs fact sheet: “If your modified adjusted gross income as reported on your IRS tax return from 2 years ago is above a certain amount, you'll pay the standard Part B premium and an income-related monthly adjustment amount,” medicare.gov, seen 2026-11-05.
- Ohio Department of Taxation, Real Property Tax, Homestead Means Testing FAQ (a 2013 homestead recipient “will not be required to disclose MAGI when applying for homestead exemption for the new property”), tax.ohio.gov, and Franklin County Auditor, Homestead FAQ (“When you move to a new residence you must reapply at the new address”), auditor.franklincountyohio.gov, both seen 2026-11-05.
- Ohio Legislative Service Commission, H.B. 186 final analysis (owner-occupancy credit rising to 15.38% by tax year 2029), effective March 20, 2026, legislature.ohio.gov, seen 2026-11-05.
Updated .
