Zillow says my house is worth X. Is that the real number?
By Aaron Leddy, REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty · Updated · 7-minute read
The short answer
A Zestimate is a useful starting point, but it isn't a price. Zillow itself says it isn't an appraisal, and it can't see inside your house, so it misses the condition, the updates, the lot and sometimes the school assignment. The real number comes from recent closed sales near you, adjusted for your house.
Send the address, and I'll pull the closed sales near it myself and show you where your house fits and why. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
Maybe you checked Zillow this morning, and the number made you happy, or maybe it made you nervous. Either way, you've got a figure in your head now, and every conversation about selling will get measured against it. That's normal, and you don't have to throw the number out.
Here's how the estimate gets made, where it tends to miss and how a real price gets built. I'm Aaron Leddy, a REALTOR® with Red 1 Realty, and pricing from nearby sales is most of what I do for sellers.
How the estimate gets made
An automated estimate is a statistical model that reads public records, like the county's square footage, bed and bath counts, lot size, past sale prices and recent sales nearby. It compares those records with thousands of other homes, so it does best on the most average houses, the ones in big, uniform subdivisions that sell often.
The further your house sits from average in age, condition, lot or style, the more the model has to guess. Its misses cancel out across thousands of homes in the statistics, but you only get one number, so the model's average accuracy doesn't help much if yours is the one that's off.
What the model can't see
The gap between an estimate and a real price almost always comes from things that are invisible in public records and obvious from the driveway, such as these:
- A kitchen, bath or lower level that was redone without a permit
- The age of the roof and the furnace, and any history of water
- Whether the lot backs to a busy road or a tree line
- A school boundary that splits the neighborhood, which is common around Central Ohio
- Square footage or an addition the county recorded wrong
None of these are unusual, and every one of them changes what a buyer will pay.
Your neighbor's asking price
A neighbor's asking price is what one hopeful seller decided to try, and the market gets to say no. Plenty of sellers this fall cut their price after the house sat for a while, so an ask tells you where a seller started more than what a buyer will pay.
The prices that count are the ones a buyer actually paid and a lender actually financed, so when a sign goes up down the street, watch what it closes for.
What a real price includes
A comparative market analysis from someone who knows the streets is what should replace the estimate. Here's what mine includes, so you know what to ask any agent for:
- Closed sales from the last few months, as close to your street as possible
- Adjustments for real differences, like a finished basement, the garage, the lot and the condition
- The school assignment, checked at the address
- How long each comparable home took to sell
- Any seller credits on each sale, since a full-price sale with a big credit didn't really close at full price
- A walk-through of your house, because condition can't be priced from a desk
It ends with a net sheet, because two identical prices can leave very different amounts in your pocket once credits, payoff and costs come out.
What a high first price costs
Starting high and coming down feels safe, but buyers can see how long a house has been listed, and they read a long stay as a sign something's wrong. Homes across Central Ohio took about 33 days to sell in September, so a house still sitting at six or eight weeks starts to stand out for the wrong reason.
A seller who starts too high can end up cutting to a lower price and then giving more back at the closing table, which is the real cost of pricing off a website.
When an appraisal makes sense
If the house is unusual, or family members disagree on what it's worth, a pre-listing appraisal from a licensed appraiser can be money well spent. Most sellers don't need one, but in an estate or a divorce, one value everyone trusts can save a lot of arguing.
See the sales behind your number
Send the address, and I'll pull the closed sales near it myself and show you where your house fits and why. I'll call or text you myself within one business day.
Sources
- Columbus REALTORS Central Ohio Housing Report, September 2026, published Oct 13, 2026: median sale price $334,250, up 2.8% from a year earlier, sellers received 96.3% of original and 98.8% of final list price, 6,530 homes for sale, up 12.3%, 33 days on market against 30 a year earlier, 2.6 months of supply, pending sales down 12.7%. Area figures come from the same release's per-area reports. columbusrealtors.com (opens in a new tab), checked Oct 25, 2026.
- Zillow, what a Zestimate is, its published accuracy, and that it is not an appraisal. zillow.com (opens in a new tab), checked Oct 25, 2026.
Updated .
